A/74/136
made about them. The findings show how children deprived of their liberty
experience fear, isolation, trauma and harm in addition to discrimination, stigma and
disempowerment.
25. Children also shared experiences of resilience and hope and highlighted the
importance of friendships with peers and adults whom they could trust and who were
working in their best interests. Many children had positive aspirations for a future
beyond detention, where they would reunite with their families and friends and enjoy
a life as independent human beings contributing to their communities. They saw
education and skills development as integral to their achieving a better life.
C.
Impact on health
26. All children have the right to the enjoyment of the highest attainable standard
of health and States shall strive to ensure that no child is deprived of hi s or her right
of access to health care services (Convention on the Rights of the Child, art. 24). In
research conducted for the study, a group of distinguished health professionals and
academics attempted to analyse the impact which deprivation of liberty of children
has on their physical and mental health. The research, informed by over 7,000
scientific articles, reveals that the particular circumstances of detention are directly
harmful to the mental and physical health of children across all situations of
deprivation of liberty.
27. Although there is a great deal of evidence that children who experience
deprivation of liberty have poor health, research shows that there is little scientific
evidence that detention is the primary factor for causing health problems, since those
children often belong to the most disadvantaged and discriminated groups, with
pre-existing or co-occurring health problems.
28. Research shows that exposure to unsanitary conditions of detention increases
the risk of infections. Overcrowded places of detention in which people with
communicable diseases and sexually transmitted infections are held promote the
spread of such diseases. Unnecessary restrictions on movement and physical activity
negatively impact the physical development of a child.
29. Many children deprived of liberty experience post-traumatic stress disorders, in
particular when in solitary confinement. Abuse or negl ect while in detention often
produce or compound mental and cognitive health problems, such as anxiety,
depression, developmental delays and even regression of language. In some cases, the
state of psychiatric disorders of children during detention as comp ared with the
mental health of the same children prior to detention increases tenfold. There is a
correlation between deprivation of liberty and higher rates of early death of children
in that situation compared with their community peers, most often due t o drug
overdose, suicide, injury and violence.
D.
Children with disabilities
30. The deprivation of liberty of children with disabilities results from the
cumulative effect of the State failure to ensure their rights in accordance with the
human rights model of disability as expressed in the Convention on the Rights of
Persons with Disabilities of 2006.
31. Children with disabilities are significantly overrepresented in detention in the
context of administration of justice and institutions. It is estimated that one out of
three children in institutions is a child with disabilities.
8/23
19-11838