CAT/C/URY/CO/3
combating crime in the State party. The Committee is also concerned by information that it
has received which indicates that the tightening of criminal legislation applicable to
juvenile offenders has led to a significant increase in the number of minors deprived of their
liberty and that this has resulted in a deterioration in their conditions of detention at
Adolescent Criminal Responsibility System (SIRPA) facilities. Although the State party
has not provided information on occupancy levels in these centres, information at the
Committee’s disposal indicates that there is overcrowding at the SER and Las Piedras
centres in Colonia Berra and that this situation is made worse by the fact that these young
people are confined to their cells for up to 23 hours a day, with no access to educational or
recreational activities. Conditions of detention at the Admissions Centre for Female
Adolescents (CIAF) and the Ceprili Detention Centre, in Montevideo, are also very poor,
with problems with regard to the water supply and sanitation facilities being noted, in
particular. The Committee is also concerned by information indicating that the adoption of
more stringent measures to prevent escapes from these centres has considerably restricted
inmates’ opportunities for contact with the outside world (arts. 2, 11 and 16).
The State party should ensure that its juvenile justice system is fully in line with
international standards, especially the United Nations Guidelines for the Prevention of
Juvenile Delinquency (Riyadh Guidelines) and the United Nations Standard
Minimum Rules for the Administration of Juvenile Justice (Beijing Rules). In
particular, the Committee urges the State party to:
(a)
Ensure that the minimum age of criminal responsibility is in accordance
with internationally established standards;
(b)
Ensure that minor offenders are deprived of their liberty only as a last
resort and for the shortest amount of time possible and that their detention is
reviewed periodically with a view to putting an end to it;
(c)
Use alternatives to pretrial detention wherever possible;
(d)
Ensure that conditions of detention in juvenile custodial centres are
consistent with the Convention and other international human rights standards and
that the minors in these centres receive care, protection, an education and job
training;
(e)
centres.
Redouble its efforts to alleviate overcrowding in juvenile detention
Juvenile facilities
13.
The Committee is gravely concerned by reports of ill-treatment of minors in SIRPA
facilities. According to the information submitted, there are documented cases of illtreatment in the form of beatings, the use of stress positions such as the “paquetito” or
“package” (shackling hands and feet behind the back), abusive or humiliating punishments,
including forced nudity, collective punishments, strip searches, invasive body searches and
the use of coercive measures within these facilities. While welcoming the additional
information provided by the delegation, according to which SIRPA has opened 16 files on
cases of ill-treatment, sexual abuse and irregularities in restraint procedures since 2012, and
criminal complaints have been brought in 3 cases arising in the SER centre, the Committee
finds it regrettable that the information does not include the number of alleged victims or
their sex and age, the place of detention concerned or the protective measures taken in each
case. Notwithstanding the delegation’s statement in which it categorically denied all
allegations that psychopharmaceutical substances are administered as a means of restraint,
the Committee remains concerned by reports indicating that there are irregularities in this
regard, particularly in respect of female juvenile detainees. Lastly, the Committee is
GE.14-04582
5