Physical conditions in segregation units: case studies
The ‘S’ security cells in Staubing prison (Germany)
Once inside the cell with all the doors closed, prisoners could not hear any of the usual prison sounds.
The cells were located at the intersection of the wings of a building and were reached through a door
opening onto a corridor, which served as a form of antechamber and where the showers were also
situated. Each corridor contained two cells. In principle, there were no guards in the corridors and the
occupants of the cells had no opportunities for visual or other forms of sensory contact with other
prisoners or prison officers [CPT report 1993, par. 74-75.]
The isolation cells in Komotini prison (Greece)
Were also not in a fit condition to hold prisoners… [cells were] hot and filthy, with a putrid smell; there
was poor ventilation, no bed (only a dirty mattress on the ground), no wash basin (hands were washed
in the toilet) and minimal access to natural light [CPT report 2006, par. 41].
The disciplinary cells at Sremska Mitrovica prison (Serbia)
Were equipped with only a wooden platform (with a mattress and bedding), a box for personal
belongings, a sink and an Asian-type toilet … access to natural light and artificial lighting were at best
mediocre [CPT report 2006, par.133].
Cells in Section 209 of Evin prison (Iran)
Were placed in the basement ... Cells measured about one meter by two meters, with a ceiling height
of about four meters. A light at the top of the cell is on twenty-four hours a day. Cells had a toilet and a
sink. The floor was made of... chalk [and] the walls were all white. Some prisoners were granted twenty
minutes per day in a caged outdoor area, but others never saw the open air... [Human Rights Watch,
“Like the Dead in Their Coffins” Torture, Detention and the Crushing of Dissent in Iran; June 2004,
Vol. 16, No.2 (E)
B. Prison regime
While it is generally accepted by human rights and monitoring bodies that certain restrictions
may be unavoidable in segregation units where solitary confinement is imposed as a short-term
disciplinary punishment, prison authorities are nonetheless required to provide prisoners with
minimal regime provisions, as prescribed in international instruments. Where prisoners are held
in longer term solitary confinement, international bodies make it clear that they must be afforded
access to prison programmes and meaningful human contact. The minimal regime provisions
prescribed by international instruments include some of the following:
Access to outdoor exercise
27.1 Every prisoner shall be provided with the opportunity of at least one hour of exercise every
day in the open air, if the weather permits.
27.2 When the weather is inclement alternative arrangements shall be made to allow prisoners
to exercise. (European Prison Rules (2006 rev.); SMR Rule 21(1))
Sourcebook on solitary confinement: Design, physical conditions and regime in solitary confinement units
43
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents