2.11
PENSION AND DISABILITY INSURANCE
CASES CONSIDERED
RESOLVED AND FOUNDED
NO. OF
RESOLVED
NO. OF
FOUNDED
PERCENTAGE OF
FOUNDED AMONG
RESOLVED
2014
2015
Index
15/14
11. Pension and disability insurance
147
163
110.9
156
14
9.0
11.1 Pension insurance
101
109
107.9
103
8
7.8
11.2 Disability insurance
46
54
117.4
53
6
11.3
FIELD OF WORK
2.11.1 General observations
Certain complainants also pointed to the unconstitutionality of provisions of the ZPIZ-2, which enable
people to undertake certain activities also after retiring, but limit the finally established right to retirement
in the relevant period. When they receive a decision reducing their pension, the affected complainants can
pursue legal remedies and exercise their legal interest with a constitutional complaint or a request for a
review of constitutionality of disputable legal provisions. Therefore, the Ombudsman chose not to request a
constitutional review, although we assess that an encroachment on the right of insured persons arising from
compulsory pension insurance is not suitable, since any possible anomalies in the activities of pensioners
could be prevented or eliminated with suitable tax arrangements which have precisely the same effect on
public resources.
Another aspect of the issue, i.e. unequal treatment of disabled people, is discussed in the chapter on
discrimination; this section includes only issues that refer to disability insurance.
2.11.2 Pension insurance
Most of the complaints in this field referred to the conditions for enforcing the right to a pension, which the
ZPIZ-2 severely limits. People were formerly able to purchase the insurance period to enable early retirement,
and they are now outraged by the provisions of the Act, which enables such purchase only in the case of
old-age retirement. They assess that the Act, which entered into force on 1 January 2013, encroaches upon
their anticipated rights, and some also claim that the Act applies retroactively. Some people demanded the
122
ANNUAL REPORT OF THE HUMAN RIGHTS OMBUDSMAN OF THE REPUBLIC OF SLOVENIA FOR 2015
ANNUAL REPORT OF THE HUMAN RIGHTS OMBUDSMAN OF THE REPUBLIC OF SLOVENIA FOR 2015
123
2.11 PENSION AND DISABILITY INSURANCE
2.10 EMPLOYMENT RELATIONS
The number of complaints involving pension and disability insurance increased in 2015 compared to 2014, while
the share of justified complaints declined from 17.3 to nine percentage points. Many complaints referred to the
constitutional review of certain provisions of the Pension and Disability Insurance Act (ZPIZ-2), which began
in summer 2015. Individuals whose possible retirements were ‘postponed’ by statutory provisions requested
information from the Ombudsman about when the Constitutional Court would make its decision, and they
expected the Ombudsman to accelerate the decision-making process. Such expectations are unfounded since
the Ombudsman cannot affect the decision making of the Constitutional Court, which is not legally bound to
reach decisions within a time limit.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents