(IND) officer who is familiar with the case
at hand waits on the stairs to the aircraft
until the actual moment of departure,
in order to deal with any last-minute
applications for admission. However,
the authorities indicate that they are
not ready to act on the CPT’s recommen
dation concerning the setting up of a
“last call procedure” before disembarkation in the country of destination.
Report on the ad hoc visit
to Spain in July 2014 and
response of the Spanish
authorities
As regards medical/nursing coverage,
the authorities indicate that they are acting upon the Committee’s recommendations, both to ensure the presence of
medical/nursing staff from the time of
departure from the detention location,
and to ensure better communication
of medical information between all the
health-care professionals involved in
the process (including in the detention
centres and on board the aircraft). As
regards a pre-departure medical examination carried out at the detainee’s
request and “fit to fly” certificates, the
authorities comment that these are not
standard procedures and further state
that they adhere to the International Air
Transport Association guidelines (i.e. that
all passengers are fit to fly in principle
unless there are medical reasons to the
contrary). The authorities also react positively to the CPT’s comment expressing
the need for a fully-equipped emergency
kit on board every official flight.
54. At the Zona Franca CIE, allegations of both physical ill-treatment and
verbal abuse of detained persons by
specific police officers were received,
and at the Aluche Centre, allegations
of insults by police officers were heard.
The CPT recommends that the Spanish
authorities act to eradicate physical illtreatment at the Zona Franca CIE and
remind staff at both centres that foreign
nationals should be treated with respect. Further, in the light of the frequent
acts of violence and intimidation among
persons detained at the Zona Franca
CIE, the Committee urges the Spanish
authorities to establish and implement
an anti-violence strategy. By contrast, at
Aluche, violence among detainees was
appropriately managed.
Moreover, the authorities also highlight
their efforts to ensure a better exchange
of knowledge and experience, including
training, between KMAR escorts and the
special escort teams of the DV&O agency
(De Dienst Vervoer en Ondersteuning).
Report and response published in
February 2015 (CPT/Inf (2015) 14
and CPT/Inf (2015) 15)
General Report of the CPT, 2015 ► Page 24
(treatment of foreign nationals in the
Aluche (Madrid) and Zona Franca
(Barcelona) detention centres for
foreigners (CIEs) and treatment of irregular
migrants attempting to enter the enclave
of Melilla)
In the report, the CPT welcomes the
adoption of Royal Decree 162/2014 of
14 March 2014, which introduces several
changes to improve the functioning of
the CIEs such as specialised compulsory
staff training modules, judicial supervision and an increase in the period of
outdoor exercise for detained persons.
However, the report is again critical of
the carceral environment at both CIEs
(e.g. barred windows, gated corridors
and cells) which is inappropriate for persons detained under aliens legislation.
Recommendations are made to address
this situation and to ensure that foreign
nationals held in multiple-occupancy
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents