VISITS BY THE
JOINT COMMISSION
Airport V Federal Police District Office in Building
177, where asylum applicants are also fingerprinted
and photographed. The delegation then accompanied
Federal Police officers to Building 587a, where
another section of Federal Police District Office V
and the Hesse Reception Centre for Refugees,
Frankfurt Airport Branch is located. After speaking
with officers of the Federal Police there, the Joint
Commission introduced itself to the head of the
facility and was shown around the building by him. It
inspected several common rooms, the courtyard, a
cinema room, Christian and Muslim prayer rooms, the
library, a sports room, the landing for men travelling
alone, and the landing for women travelling alone,
families and minors who are regarded as capable of
acting in the asylum procedure (“asylmündig
Minderjährige”). They also spoke to a member of the
church refugee support group of the Caritasverband
Frankfurt e.V. (the Frankfurt branch of the welfare
association of the Catholic Church in Germany) and a
member of the Diakonisches Werk Frankfurt (the
Frankfurt branch of the social welfare organisation of
the Protestant Church in Germany), as well as to a
vicar.
As the visit took place in late 2013 the Ministry of
Social Affairs and Integration of Hesse had not yet
submitted its statement at the time this Annual
Report went to press. It will be included in the Annual
Report 2014.
families are kept separate from the other adults.
According to the social worker, in one case this led to
an under-age refugee witnessing an adult attempting
suicide. The Ministry for Social Affairs and
Integration of Hesse admitted after the visit that the
case most likely involved an underage female who was
to be separated from her adult husband, as she had to
be taken into care by the Youth Welfare Office. The
husband thereupon attempted to hang himself using
bed sheets. The incident was still being investigated.
As well as this individual case, the Joint Commission
has
fundamental
concerns
about
whether
accommodating minors travelling alone and families
with underage children together with adults is in the
children’s best interests. Due to the especially
stressful situation which those accommodated in the
Reception Centre are generally under, it seems
reasonable to assume that there is an increased risk of
self-harm or suicide. This can lead to trauma or can
exacerbate existing traumatisation, especially when
minors experience such incidents or resistance against
the enforcement of forced returns.
The Joint Commission welcomes the fact that each
time a person is booked in they are examined by a
doctor as soon as possible. However, special attention
should be paid during these examinations to
diagnosing traumatisation and suicidal tendencies.
The examining doctor should have been specially
trained in diagnosing trauma and other mental
illnesses, or he or she should bring in a specially
trained psychologist. It must be ensured that
traumatisation is accurately diagnosed.
Detainees are informed of the house rules by means
of notices hung in the common room in Arabic,
English, French and Tamil. The rules also contain
information about rights. An excerpt of this
information is handed to new admissions in the form
of a leaflet with pictogrammes. The house rules
regulate the community life of those accommodated
in the facility and can help to prevent conflicts arising.
As is the case in facilities enforcing custody pending
deportation, these house rules should therefore be
available in various languages based on the detainees’
most common countries of origin.
1.10.1 – Positive findings
The Reception Centre is clean, light and has
modern furnishings. Detainees can use two common
rooms with a TV which receives numerous foreign TV
stations. In addition, there are two telephones which
can be used for both incoming and outgoing calls.
Further, there is a modern courtyard with a play area
and a tartan field with a football pitch, as well as
seating and green spaces. Detainees are free to move
around the facility all day and night and can use the
courtyard at any time. The Joint Commission
welcomes the fact that women and men are
accommodated in separate rooms but not in separate
areas.
Detainees can contact the church social service
between 7 am and 9 pm every day. An on-call service is
available at night. In addition, a doctor holds surgery
twice a week in the facility.
1.10.3 – Further suggestions for improving the
conditions of detention
Women and juveniles can lock the doors to their
rooms. It is not apparent why this opportunity is
denied the men.
The staff of the church social service reported about
cases in which the medical and psychological
examination identified problems but these were not
passed on the Federal Police, who nevertheless began
the procedure for returning the persons in question. It
1.10.2 – Recommendations of the Joint
Commission
Neither minors travelling alone who are regarded as
capable of acting in the asylum procedure (i.e. they are
over the age of 16) nor minors travelling with their
67
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents