-51
When interviews take place in the cell that the detainee is occupying (e.g.
an isolation cell), it is possible to also note the conditions s/he is subjected
to. Interviews can also take place in other appropriate areas. Detainees
should be unrestrained and should not be divided from the interviewer by
any partition (e.g. bars or glass).
Some NPMs organise the first part of the interview with open questions
to give the opportunity to detainees to say what they think to be most
important. Afterwards, the NPM can ask specific questions to review the
various aspects of solitary confinement, such as:
• The way the medical examination is carried out;
• The material conditions of detention facilities;
• The regime to which they are subjected (daily exercise in open air,
medical treatment, smoking, personal objects…)
• Whether they know how long their isolation measure will last;
• Which contacts they have with prison staff (and how the prison
staff treats them), family members and their lawyer (to measure
meaningful social contacts);
• Whether they know of a complaint mechanism and how it works;
• Whether they had the possibility to defend themselves in the
disciplinary hearing;
• Whether they have suffered any abuse or ill-treatment or if they know
whether other isolated detainees have suffered them.
• How they feel and whether they think solitary confinement is affecting
their mental and physical health.
With regard to interviews with staff, it has emerged as a good practice that
some NPMs hold initial group meetings with staff without the presence
of the director, and in that context they raise the issue of isolation and
discuss with them their problems and any possible alternatives. Another
good practice that was pointed out during the online conference for the
presentation of the Handbook is also to have individual meetings with
members of prison staff (all types of professionals). Indeed a one-onone meeting (even in a casual setting) can better bring to the surface not
only what an individual really thinks, but also the dynamics, the way the
Monitoring Solitary Confinement in Prison
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents