-55
NPMs ask staff how prisoners can tell the passing of time (and
specifically whether or not they have access to a watch).
4.3.7. Role of medical staff
Because of the particularly serious effects that solitary confinement has on
isolated people, effective monitoring by the medical authorities operating
in prisons is of critical importance. Many NPMs stressed that often doctors
lack the necessary awareness regarding their role and highlighted the need
to strengthen it also through specific training. A first problem relates to
the visit of a medical doctor, which should take place prior to isolation
to verify whether the detainee is in conditions to be able to cope with it:
NPMs found that frequently this visit does not take place.
A second issue that needs to be verified by NPMs is whether doctors visit
all persons placed in isolation daily. In some cases, NPMs found that this
is true only for prisoners who are isolated for disciplinary reasons. If the
national legislation does not provide for an obligation to visit all isolated
detainees, the NPM may appeal to the basic obligations of medical personnel.
Another aspect to be monitored concerns the way the visits are carried
out. They should take place inside the cell, and also allow the doctor to
assess the living conditions of the person examined. They should not take
place outside the accommodation section, e.g. in the infirmary, and not
outside the cell, through the steel door. Visits by doctors often take place
through the hatch of the door. A meaningful interaction cannot take place
through the hatch of the door since it does not guarantee the privacy
and confidentiality of the visit and, more generally, it is disrespectful to
interact in this way.
A further problematic aspect (that may emerge from the study of the
medical records of isolated persons and interviews) concerns cases where
isolation measures are carried out in so-called smooth cells (bare cells
without furniture or only with a mattress often placed on the floor). This
form of isolation is prescribed by medical staff as a reaction to acts of
self-harm or suicide attempts. It is a totally inadequate reaction, as there
Monitoring Solitary Confinement in Prison
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents