40
INTERNATIONAL LEGAL PROTECTION OF HUMAN RIGHTS IN ARMED CONFLICT
the parties to a conflict to recognize that actual armed conflict exists. This
determination must be made primarily on the basis of the situation on the
ground, according to the relevant provisions of international humanitarian
law. In addition, public statements by ICRC or the United Nations would
be significant in determining that there is an armed conflict.
Why is it important to determine when the applicability of international
humanitarian rules has been triggered? International human rights law
and international humanitarian law share a number of protections and
standards aimed at protecting civilians from the effects of war. Yet, because
international humanitarian law gives States more leeway when they use
armed force (for example, on the use of deadly force) and, according
to certain States, when they detain enemies without judicial procedure
(like prisoners of war in international armed conflicts), there may be a
temptation to invoke rules of international humanitarian law in a situation
where the threshold of armed force has not been reached. In those unclear
cases it is essential to consider international human rights law as the only
applicable legal regime, until such time that the threshold and conditions
of an armed conflict have been met.
3. The distinction between international and non-international armed
conflict in contemporary law and practice
At various moments in history efforts have been made to remove the
distinction between international and non-international armed conflicts in
order to create a single body of international humanitarian law common
to all situations of armed conflict. Although these efforts have not been fully
successful, developments in case law, international practice and the actual
character of armed conflict are de facto blurring the distinction between
the two. As a result, the higher protections previously ascribed only to
international armed conflicts, or only to the more formal non-international
armed conflicts defined under Protocol II, are now being applied even to
the category of conflict defined under common article 3.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents