Annual Report 2010 by the National Preventive Mechanism against Torture
The standard of cleanliness
54. The standards of cleanliness found in cells were satisfactory in most cases,
of cells was satisfactory in
though with room for improvement. However they were clearly unacceptable
most cases, but clearly
unacceptable in some
facilities
in some establishments, including the stations in Cordoba and the Central
District of Madrid, where it was requested that measures be taken to improve
cleanliness. In some cases, e.g. the police station of Leon, it was recommended
that the contracts for cell cleaning should be changed to ensure that cleaning
services are available at weekends when necessary. The standard of upkeep and
hygiene of the toilet facilities inspected was in general acceptable, though there
were exceptions, e.g. the Central District police station in Madrid and the Western
Andalusia Police Headquarters [Jefatura Superior de Policía de Andalucía Occidental]
in Seville, where there were two blocked urinals filled with urine, and the station
in Tarragona, where one of the urinals was unusable due to the level of the
septic tank. Those cells inspected that had internal toilets were generally in
good condition.
Some establishments have
55. EIt was observed that CCTV surveillance at establishments run by the
modern CCTV surveillance
CNP generally covered the entrance and corridors of holding cell areas but not
equipment and others have
obsolete equipment
the interior of the cells. Some were equipped with modern recording equipment
while at others the equipment was obsolete and the images obtained were not
sharp. The need for improvements in technical equipment was indicated at the
police headquarters in Asturias and Murcia, and at the district police stations of
Cartagena (Murcia), Elche (Alicante), Jerez de la Frontera (Cadiz), Lleida and
Playa de Palma de Mallorca (Balearic Islands). To improve surveillance of
detainees while they are in the cells, it was also requested that CCTV cameras
be installed in the custody areas of the district stations of A Coruña, Aviles and
Gijon (Asturias), Caceres, Cadiz, Elche and Leon and the police headquarters in
Asturias, Extremadura (in Badajoz) and Melilla.
Cells have no mixed or
56. Most of the establishments visited were observed to have extinguishers,
mechanical opening
fire hoses and smoke detectors, though the cells have no mixed or mechanical
system to evacuate
detainees in an emergency
opening systems for emergency evacuation of detainees. This Office requested
that evacuation routes be signposted urgently and that suitable emergency
measures be set in place at the police headquarters in Ceuta and Castilla-La
Mancha (Toledo) and the city police stations in Cadiz, Jerez de Frontera, Ibiza,
Lugo, the Central District (where it was deemed necessary to re-evaluate the
entire evacuation plan), Chamartín District and San Blas-Vicálvaro District
stations in Madrid, and in Torrelavega (Cantabria), Torremolinos (Málaga)
and Tudela (Navarre).
When direct voice
communication with
57. In holding areas whose size or layout means that the detainees cannot
detainees is not possible,
talk directly to staff, intercom or other call systems need to be installed. This
52
THE OMBUDSMAN OF SPAIN
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents