Child and youth welfare facilities
Facilities run under the child and youth welfare regime usually have
substantially more resources than facilities that have to survive on the basis of
daily rates for reception conditions under the Basic Provision Agreement and
that can thus only implement lower standards. Furthermore, the Laender have
also developed their own approach when it comes to the care of unaccompanied
minor refugees. After visits by Commission 3 in Styria in recent years, the NPM
criticised several times that the regional government authorised quarters for
unaccompanied minor refugees exclusively as residential homes with a 1:15
staffing ratio unlike in other Laender where they are authorised predominantly
as residential groups with a 1:10 staffing ratio. In larger facilities, this meant
that the risk of many avoidable problems was accepted. A new Basic Welfare
Support Act regulation in mid-2017 enabled Styria to at least draw level with
other Laender with respect to staffing ratios. The benchmark for approved
places was reduced from 40 to 30 and a somewhat higher daily rate for crisis
care places was introduced. Throughout the country, there is a lack of special
socio-therapeutic care places for unaccompanied minor refugees, which exist
neither nationwide nor in sufficient numbers.
NPM observed many
deficiencies
In 2017 the commissions noticed repeatedly that unaccompanied minor
refugees with a seriously problematic background frequently changed
facilities after a relatively short time. Despite clear indications of a mental
illness requiring treatment or entrenched addictive behaviour, they showed
no willingness to undergo psychiatric assessment or this was not performed
due to a lack of services. Some of these unaccompanied minor refugees can
only be accommodated in residential groups for a limited time before going
missing again. It appears that it is not possible to build up a relationship using
conventional concepts to those who are most in need of intensive support.
The long waiting times for therapy places additionally thwart all efforts to
counteract the risk behaviour.
The NPM observed repeatedly that the needs of minors in reception conditions
under the Basic Provision Agreement are not sufficiently met, even though the
situation has improved considerably compared to 2015 due to the decrease
in new arrivals. Nevertheless, the list of deficiencies observed in 2017 is long
and shocking in parts. It must be emphasised, however, that the caregivers
themselves perform their work with great dedication.
Not enough qualified
personnel
80
The management of facilities for unaccompanied minor refugees is responsible
for providing a non-discriminatory and inclusive working environment. But
it has to proactively prevent the potential work overload of the staff. It is
indisputable that in many facilities not enough staff are employed or their
qualifications are inadequate. There is rarely enough time to train in new
members of staff. In extreme cases, as observed by Commission 4 in Vienna
for example, this is limited to working one single shift with an experienced
member of staff before taking over night shifts alone. The lack of pedagogic
support concepts in the face of the imminent risk of radicalisation was also
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents