E/CN.4/1996/35/Add.1
page 71
382. The allegations concerning the imprisonment of medical practitioners who
refused to implement the decrees were unfounded and false. There was no
record of the existence of a Dr. Tawfiq Abdullah Khalid in any governate.
Dr. Yahya al-Khafaji and Dr. Rabi’Abdul Hadi were working for the Department
of Health in the governate of Dhi Qar at Saddam public hospital and carrying
out their duties in a normal manner. Dr. Abbas Qalander was head of the
Dental Section of the Department of Health in the governate of Neineva. There
was no physician in Baghdad practising under the name Dr. Nahrain Youssuf.
Dr. Salih Muhammad was a recently graduated physician who was performing
compulsory military service.
383. The Government sent a further communication on 15 September 1995 to which
was attached five letters signed by doctors - Dr. Abbas Kalander Shahban,
Dr. Abbas Kalander Ahmed, Dr. Yahya Hadi Ayod, Dr. Rabee Abdul Hadi Faroun and
Dr. Shaleh Mohammad Ahmed al-Sharabi - stating that they had not been
subjected to any form of harassment or pressure by the authorities or their
agents and that they practised their medical professions and enjoyed a normal
life with their families.
Israel
Information transmitted to the Government
384. By letter dated 14 July 1995 the Special Rapporteur advised the
Government that he had continued to receive information according to which
Palestinians undergoing interrogation by the General Security Service (GSS or
Shin Bet) are often subjected to torture or ill-treatment. The methods of
torture reported include: beatings all over the body, sometimes with cables;
hooding, sometimes with dirty and wet sacks which interfere with respiration;
prolonged standing or sitting in painful and contorted positions (shabeh);
sleep deprivation; confinement in closet-shaped rooms (kahzana); food
deprivation; threats of disablement; and continuous subjection to loud music.
385. Israeli Criminal Procedure Law permits persons charged with State
security offences to be held incommunicado for up to 30 days, the first 15 of
which may be kept secret. Such periods of incommunicado detention create
conditions which facilitate the practice of torture. Military orders applying
to the Occupied Territories were said to permit detention without judicial
review for up to 11 days and denial of access to a lawyer for a total of
90 days on security grounds.
386. The Landau Commission guidelines sanctioning "the exertion of a moderate
measure of physical pressure" were allegedly applied in a way so as to allow
for torture and ill-treatment. Because the guidelines are secret, it was
impossible to assess the extent to which the above-mentioned practices were
consistent with or a departure from them. The ministerial committee which
meets monthly to review the guidelines was said to have allowed for the
increased use of physical pressure in the aftermath of the October 1994
suicide bombing in Tel Aviv.
387. The Special Rapporteur also sent the cases of alleged torture summarized
in the following paragraphs.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents