Gigi Scoles and Anupama Selvam
15
tial and must be followed by prosecutions where there is a legitimate finding to do so.49 To ensure
that investigations of gender-based violence are prompt and impartial, training of the actors con
ducting the investigations is integral. Again, law enforcement must not only have knowledge of
the laws that may protect victims, but they must also approach each case without bias—something
that may be difficult where cultural biases and stereotyping exist.50
The Justice Institute provides participants with concrete examples of how to investigate and
prosecute cases involving gender-based violence through various exercises designed for specific
communities. Role plays, multi-media, lectures, discussions and other types of activities that bring
together law enforcement, prosecutors, judges, social workers, and other State actors facilitate the
exploration and deconstruction of biases surrounding gender-based violence, while providing spe
cific instructions on how individuals within the justice system can improve their investigation
methods and gather the best evidence for prosecution.
Punishment. Where a fair investigation and prosecution finds that an individual has perpe
trated gender-based violence, States are required to hold perpetrators accountable for their actions.
Without punishment, prosecution lacks an enforcement mechanism and fails to create a State that
protects victims of gender-based violence. If a victim reports abuse and an investigation and pros
ecution find that gender-based violence occurred but perpetrators fail to be held accountable, then
the victim fails to be made whole, effectively blocking them from accessing justice. Therefore, the
development and application of adequate punishment must be part of fulfilling due diligence.
The Justice Institute provides guidance for judges to sentence perpetrators to proportionate pun
ishment. Trainers facilitate activities that give context to the offense and allow judges to think more
broadly about what remedies would be in the best interests of all parties involved. Fact-finders are
encouraged to consider power differentials and social influences that provide the backdrop to the
offenses committed. This can result in a more tailored and appropriate sentence in each individual
case. More appropriate and effective sentencing leads to fair punishment allowing the State to
move toward meeting this prong of its due diligence obligation.
Reparations. States can provide reparations in five ways: (1) restitution or measures to restore
victims to their original situations, (2) compensation for economic assessable damage, (3) rehabil
itation, (4) satisfaction, (5) guarantees of non-repetition. Reparations are necessary for victims of
gender-based violence to be made whole, to heal and move forward with their lives. Providing
victims of torture and other serious international crimes is a well-established principle in interna
tional law.51
The benefits of the Justice Institute to the provision of reparation is not as obvious as the other
prongs of due diligence, however, there are several concrete ways that the Justice Institute con
tributes to a State’s ability to provide each of these types of reparations. First, in order to pro
vide proportionate restitution or compensation to victims, judges and other State actors must be
knowledgeable about the harm suffered by victims. Deciding the amount and type of restitution
necessary to restore a victim to their previous situation or to compensate for assessable damage,
means understanding the underlying power dynamics of gender-based violence. More specifically,
a judge that holds gender-based stereotypes or does not grasp the harm caused by gender-based
49
See Convention against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment Art. 5
and 7, Dec. 10, 1984, 1465 U.N.T.S. 85.
50
See Rebecca J. Cook and Simone Cusack, Gender Stereotyping: Transnational Legal Perspectives 26 (University
of Pennsylvania Press, 2010).
51
See Abdul Aziz and Moussa, supra note 6 at 13.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents