23
1. THE ACTIVITIES AND ACHIEVEMENTS OF THE COMMISSIONER FOR FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS AND HIS DEPUTIES IN 2019
system: legal protection provided by the Ombudsman, the system
of nationality self-governments, and statutory regulation.
The number of petitions in 2019
In 2019, the number of nationality cases (complaints and impropri-
1. The six-year mandate of Dr. Elisabeth Sándor-Szalay
expired on 21 October 2019, which meant that in accordance with the Fundamental Law of Hungary and the CFR
Act, the Commissioner had to nominate a new candidate
for the position. During the obligatory consultation procedure, the Association of National Self-Governments of
the Nationalities and the Standing Committee on National
Minorities in Hungary of the Parliament assured the outgoing Deputy Commissioner of their unanimous support, thus
she was nominated for the position again, in concert, by the
outgoing and incoming Commissioners. On 4 November
2019, with the support of nearly 80% of the MPs, the
National Assembly re-elected Dr. Elisabeth SándorSzalay as Deputy Commissioner for Fundamental Rights,
Ombudsman for the Protection of the Rights of National
Minorities in Hungary. Her mandate lasts for six years, i.e.
till 3 November 2025.
2. The general elections of nationality self-governments
were held on 13 October 2019, which meant a simultaneous
renewal of representation on the settlement, regional and
national levels. As a result of the elections, nearly 2,200 settlement-level and 62 regional national self-governments were
formed, and all thirteen nationalities recognised in Hungary
set up their respective national self-governments as well.
eties examined ex officio) rose to 409, which was a 6% increase over
the figures of 2018. During the first term of Deputy Commissioner Dr.
Elisabeth Sándor-Szalay, the annual number of cases grew by two and
a half times, which is a significant increase and is a clear indication
of the fact that after the transformation of the Ombudsman system,
the institution of the Deputy Commissioner for Fundamental Rights,
Ombudsman for the Rights of National Minorities has become, over
the past years, increasingly well-known and recognised among the
members and representatives of the nationality communities.
The nationality of the petitioners
Similarly to the previous years, the highest number of cases concerned citizens of Roma nationality in 2019 which is evidence of the
fact that many citizens of Roma nationality struggle with livelihood
and housing difficulties, as well as with the practical implementation
of the requirement of equal treatment. The number of German and
Slovak petitions was especially high: the bulk of these complaints
were related to individual and collective nationality rights, nationality self-governments, and nationality institutions maintained by
the latter. The number of cases pertaining to several or all of the
nationality communities continued to rise, and they were mostly
connected to education, cultural rights, the operation and financing
of nationality self-governments, and comments on legislation.
The types and subject matters of the petitions in 2019
3. The third outstanding professional challenge of last year
In 2019, the subject matters and their distribution were similar
was the preparation of the comprehensive amendment
to last year, and clearly, there is still a classical polarisation of
of the Act on the Rights of Nationalities. Based on her ju-
petitions between cases concerning nationality and Roma equal
risprudence-related experience and specific professional
opportunities, and cases related to equal treatment, as indicated
materials accumulated over the previous years, the Deputy
several times above. This also determined the methodology of
Commissioner contributed to the joint efforts by making 27
complaints processing. The green fields of the diagram typically
technical and 31 substantive overarching proposals aimed
represent petitions belonging to the former category, whereas the
at the elimination of the anomalies encountered in practice
blue ones stand for petitions in connection with the latter.
and at the necessary improvement of the legislation.
2019
2018
2017
2016
2015
2014
2013
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
Number of petitions and ex officio inquiries, 2013–2019
350
400
450
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents