Chapter 4. Observing the rights of military personnel, police officers, retired military service personnel,
veterans and their family members
97
Example
The Commissioner was approached by the father of serviceman S., who reported that his son had been
seriously injured during his capture by representatives of the Federal Security Service of the Russian
Federation. The prisoner of war was not given a proper medical examination and was not provided
with necessary primary health care. The Commissioner sent official letters to representatives of the
Russian authorities, drawing attention to serviceman S.’s right to medical examination and assistance
from medical personnel of the relevant authorities of the aggressor country, as set forth in international
humanitarian law. As a result of these letters, S. was immediately examined and received appropriate
medical care.
Forcing prisoners of war to remove their uniforms
The Commissioner undertook monitoring of the conditions of prisoners and detainees in places of
temporary detention and imprisonment, which revealed that the representatives of illegal armed groups
and the aggressor state had violated the right of prisoners of war to wear uniforms with distinctive
insignia in captivity and deprived them of their identity documents.
Monitoring undertaken by the Commissioner of the conditions of military personnel detained by the
Russian Federation in temporary detention facilities revealed systematic and persistent violations
of international law on the proper quality of healthcare for detainees, including emergency care,
examinations and surgeries, by representatives of public authorities of the aggressor country
Example
In September 2019, a medical examination of serviceman H. at the National Military Medical Clinical Centre
“Main Military Clinical Hospital” revealed that he had developed a tumour as a result of the conditions
under which he had been held captive. If the tumour had been removed in the military medical institution,
this would have resulted in the discharge of the serviceman from military service for health reasons.
With the participation and support of the Commissioner, specialists from foreign clinics were involved
in the treatment, including surgery, which meant that H. was able to continue with his military service
once the tumour had been removed.
Violation of the right to legal protection during detention, and prosecution, and in court proceedings
Representatives of public authorities of the Russian Federation are systematically denying detainees
the right to access qualified legal assistance and to consult with lawyers of their choice, or to access
CHAPTER 4
Lack of healthcare during the detention of prisoners in the Russian Federation
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents