PART A – Dermatological findings after alleged torture
Two parallel linear lesions (“tramline bruises”) result from a blow with a rod or stick
(Knight, 1991a). The haemorrhagic areas
often move down the body during the following days. Deep tissue bruises might not
be seen on the surface. The lesions change
colour from dark red, to dusky purple, to
brown, to green, to yellow and to hyperpigmented brown, or they disappear.
Severe beating on the soles of the feet, “Falanga”, may leave contusions in the arch of
the feet and swelling of the feet extending
from the arch to the medial aspects of the
feet and ankles (Bro-Rasmussen & Rasmussen, 1978).
Blunt trauma often leaves no or uncharacteristic scars (Cohn et al., 1978). Flogging
or beating with canes or truncheons may,
however, leave characteristic scars, e.g.
asymmetric, linear, straight or curved or
“tramline”-shaped scars, showing a pattern of external infliction (Danielsen, 1992;
Petersen & Rasmussen, 1992; Forrest 1999).
The scars may be hypertrophic with a narrow, regular, hyperpigmented area in the
periphery, representing “arrowline” bruises
or an inflammatory zone appearing around
necrotic tissue in the acute phase (Fig. 1)
(Danielsen, 1992).
≠≠ A differential diagnosis could be plant
dermatitis, usually dominated, however,
by shorter scars, with a narrow zone of
hyperpigmentation in the periphery.
In one case, the alleged torture was beating and scalding on the back. Symmetrical, atrophic, depigmented, linear changes
typical for striae distensae were observed on
the back and in both axillary regions (Fig.
2) (Danielsen, 1992). The skin changes could
not support the history of torture. The patient, however, may have been unaware of
the changes on the back before the torture.
Prolonged application of tight ligatures may
leave a linear zone extending circularly
7
around the arm or leg, in one case with lack
of hair indicating cicatricial alopecia (Danielsen & Berger, 1981).
≠≠ No differential diagnosis in the form of a
spontaneous skin disease exists because
of the location of the scar.
3. SHARP TRAUMA
Sharp trauma, e.g. caused by the use of a razor blade, knife or bayonet, gives characteristic ulcers and usually leaves recognisable
scars. In some cases, self-infliction should
be considered, particularly when located on
a wrist (Danielsen, 1992, Petersen & Rasmussen, 1992). If pepper is applied to the open
wounds, the scars may become hypertrophic
(Danielsen, 1992).
≠≠ A differential diagnosis could be traditional healers, African ritual scar-tattoos
or art on the body (Nancke-Krogh, 1985).
In one case, where the deepness of a scar,
allegedly following the use of a sword, was
doubted, the use of a high-frequency ultrasound could demonstrate a considerable,
deep scar (Gniadecka & Danielsen, 1995).
Afterwards, the patient was granted refugee
status.
4. THERMAL INJURIES
Burning with cigarettes, hot instruments or hot fluids leaves acute
burns of varying degrees. Burning
is the form of torture that most frequently leaves scars, often of diagnostic value.
Cigarette burns often leave 5-10 mm large,
circular and macular scars with a depigmented centre and a hyperpigmented, rela-