PART A – Dermatological findings after alleged torture
13
II. MICROSCOPIC CHANGES
If a victim agrees, a 3-4 mm punch
biopsy, under local anaesthesia,
might be helpful in supporting an
allegation of electrical torture (Danielsen et al., 1978; Danielsen et al.,
1978, Thomsen et al., 1983; Karlsmark et al., 1984, Karlsmark et al.,
1988; Danielsen et al., 2003; Thomsen, 1984; Karlsmark, 1990).
Previously, only few cases of electrical torture
have been studied histologically (Danielsen et
al., 1991; Öztop, Lök, Baykal & Tunca, 1994;
Danielsen, Karlsmark & Thomsen, 1997; TATGroup against Torture, 2001).
Only in one case, in which lesions were excised seven days after the injury, were alterations in the skin diagnostic of electrical injuries observed (deposition of calcium salts on
dermal fibres in viable tissue located around
necrotic tissue at the surface and on collagen fibres deep in the dermis).
Lesions excised a few days after the alleged
electric torture showed segmental changes
and deposits of calcium salts on cellular
structures, consistent with the influence of
an electric current, but with only a moderate
degree of support.
A biopsy taken one month after the alleged
electrical torture showed a conical scar, 1-2
mm broad, with an increased number of fibroblasts and tightly packed, thin collagen
fibres arranged in parallel to the surface,
consistent with electrical injury, but with
only a slight degree of support.
A biopsy taken five days after alleged electrical torture via the use of a battery-driven
electrical instrument, probably delivering
high-frequency alternating current, where
the concomitant heat development dominates, showed non-specific alterations with
subepidermal bullae consistent with thermal injuries.
≠≠ Toxic contact dermatitis could be a differential diagnosis, the support to the
history of torture being of a slight degree.
Even if an examination does not
reveal any abnormal findings, the
possible use of electrical torture
cannot be excluded.
The use of high-frequency ultrasound may
be helpful in discovering the location of calcium deposits in order to select an area for
biopsy (Danielsen, 2002)
(For more information refer to chapter V, sections
C.1, D.1 and D.5 of the Istanbul Protocol).
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents