24
A practical guide to the Istanbul Protocol – for medical doctors
tures are easily felt through the tissues. The
pathophysiology of the reduced elasticity in
the heel pad is thought to be tearing of the
connective tissue septa, leading to deprivation of blood supply and secondary atrophy
of fat cells with loss of the shock absorbing
ability.
Damaged footpads are not pathognomonic
of falanga, but are also described in connection with other conditions unrelated to
torture, e.g. lesions in long-distance runners
and patients with fractures of the heel bone.
It should also be stressed that normal footpads at clinical examination does not rule
out exposure to falanga.
Changes in the plantar fascia
The plantar fascia springs from the calcaneus and proceeds to the forefoot. It supports the longitudinal arches of the foot,
assisting the foot muscles during walking.
Changes in the plantar fascia are present in
some torture victims after falanga and are
probably due to the repeated direct traumas
to this superficial structure. After falanga,
the fascia may appear thickened with an uneven surface at palpation, and tenderness
may be found throughout the whole length
of the fascia, from its spring to the insertion.
Disruption of the plantar fascia has been
reported, based on the finding of increased
passive dorsiflexion in the toes at clinical
examination (Forrest, 2002; Skylv, 1992).
Closed compartment syndrome
The plantar muscles of the foot are arranged
in tight compartments – an anatomical arrangement which makes it possible for a
closed compartment syndrome to develop. A
closed compartment syndrome is defined as
a painful ischaemic, circulatory disturbance
in connection with an increase in pressure
and volume inside a well-defined muscle
compartment. In the acute form, with a
rapidly increasing pressure, e.g. caused by
bleeding inside the compartment, the symptoms are alarming and the consequences severe with necrosis of involved tissues if left
untreated.
Chronic compartment syndromes may occur
as a result of an increase in the muscle bulk
and/or a narrowing of the compartment.
Clinically, this condition presents itself with
pain that intensifies with load and which
finally makes continued muscle activity impossible. The pain subsides after a short period of rest, but recurs if muscle activity is
resumed – a picture not unlike that seen in
impaired walking after falanga.
In a MRI study comparing torture victims
exposed to falanga with healthy volunteers,
significant thickening of the plantar fascia
was found in all victims. Apart from this,
morphological changes were present in the
fascia, possibly representing scar tissue formation. No signs of detachment of the plantar fascia, closed compartment syndrome or
changes in the heel pads were shown in this
study (Savnik et al., 2000).
Neurogenic pain
The skin of the soles in the normal foot is
apart from the arch area, very thick and firmly tied to the underlying tissues. It is very
rich in sensory nerve endings, which register
touch and pressure. Peripheral nerve lesion
affecting the small nerves of the soles is a
very possible consequence of falanga. Neurogenic pain due to nerve lesion is therefore
a possible contributing pain mechanism.
Impaired walking
Deviations from the normal gait pattern
are very frequent after exposure to falanga.
Many torture victims develop a compensa-
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents