10.3. The authorities’ responses to the major measures taken by the NPM
beyond hearing distance. I was informed by the head of the Metropolitan
Police Headquarters of Budapest that police presence at the medical examination of the detainees was also allowed in lack of the detainee’s consent,
by 227 respecting his human rights and dignity. The police staff stay in the
room during the pre-admission medical examination at the request of the
medical personnel, in order to guarantee their safety. I did not accept the
response given by the head of the Metropolitan Police Headquarters of Budapest, I maintained my recommendation.
As the head of the Metropolitan Police Headquarters of Budapest did not
agree with my initiative, he escalated it to the National Police Headquarters.228
The deputy head of the Hungarian National Police Headquarters said
that in the doctor ’s office, there are many objects within the reach of the
detainees that are suitable for jeopardising the physical integrity of the
detainees or others. The risk of emergency situations increases if the policeman stays not only out of eyeshot but also beyond hearing distance
during the medical examination of the detainee. The majority of medical
history information that is shared during the medical examination of the
detainee may be of such kind that may exert an unfavourable effect on
detention and guarding, so these should definitely be obtained. I acknowledged the response given by the National Police Headquarters but I maintained my recommendation.
I requested the head of the Metropolitan Police Headquarters of Budapest
to provide food for those detainees who arrive at the Holding Facility late in
the evening after dinner time, if requested. According to the head of the
Metropolitan Police Headquarters of Budapest, there is a sufficient quantity
of cold food and food that can be warmed up at the Holding Facility. The
staff of the Holding Facility asks the detainees arriving after dinner time to
make a statement on whether or not they would like food. If requested, each
detainee will be given food.
With regard to the adverse effects of detention in single cells, which are
similar to those of confinement in a private cell, I proposed that the detainees staying at the Holding Facility be placed in multi-occupancy cells
if possible. The head of the Metropolitan Police Headquarters of Budapest
promised to provide the space required by law for the joint placement of
the detainees in all the cells of the Institution after the refurbishment of the
Holding Facility has been completed.
As a response to my recommendation regarding the improvement of
the work conditions of the personnel, the head of the Metropolitan Police
227
228
See Note b), Section 14(1) of Act XLVII of 1997 on the Processing and Protection of Medical
and Other Related Personal Data.
See Section 32(3) of the Ombudsman Act.
111
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents