5.2. Conducting the visits
5.2.3. Interviews
Pursuant to Section 39/B(3)c) of the Ombudsman Act, the NPM shall “hear any
person present on the site, including the personnel of the authority under inspection
and any persons deprived of their liberty”.
By virtue of Article 20(e) of the OPCAT, the NPMs shall have the liberty
to choose “the persons they want to interview”. The management and the personnel of the place of detention inspected as well as their supervisors shall
cooperate with the visiting delegation and its members.87 The members of
the visiting delegation conduct, on the basis of pre-compiled questionnaires,
interviews with the head and the personnel of the place of detention, as well
as any other persons staying on the premises at the time of the visit.
Pursuant to Section 39/B(4) of the Ombudsman Act, in the hearing, “apart
from the person who is given a hearing, no other person may participate, unless the
Commissioner for Fundamental Rights authorized their participation”.
The visiting delegations aim at conducting tête-à-têtes, but, occasionally,
group hearings are conducted as well.
Interviews are usually conducted with no witnesses present; in exceptional cases, members of the security personnel may be present outside
hearing distance. The only exception to that was the visit made to Unit I
of the Budapest Remand Prison. Here, despite the multiple warnings of
the visiting delegation, one of the custodial officers stayed within hearing distance and was taking notes throughout the interviews conducted
with the detainees and the members of the staff. In my report on this visit,
I asked the Director General of the Hungarian Prison Service to call the
attention of the personnel under his command to comply fully with their
obligations with a view to the enforcement of my rights and those of my
authorised colleagues88 during the performance of the NPM’s tasks, as
stipulated by Section 39/B(3)c) of the Ombudsman Act and Section 39/B(4)
of the Ombudsman Act.89
The persons deprived of their liberty, unlike the head and the personnel
of the place of detention concerned, are not compelled to cooperate with
the visiting delegation. In the case of persons deprived of their liberty who,
due to their age, state of health, or any other circumstance, are not able or
willing to give an account of their detention-related experiences, the visiting delegation inspects the conditions of their placement. The objective of
the members of the visiting delegation is to meet, if possible, all persons
deprived of their liberty staying on the premises at the time of the visit.
87
88
89
See Sections 25(1) and 39/D(1) of the Ombudsman Act.
See Section 39/D(1) of the Ombudsman Act.
See in details in Report No. AJB-501/2018.
47
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents