24
Prison overcrowding
28.
The phenomenon of prison overcrowding continues to blight penitentiary systems
across Europe and seriously undermines attempts to improve conditions of detention. The
negative effects of prison overcrowding have already been highlighted in previous General
Reports.1 As the CPT’s field of operations has extended throughout the European continent,
the Committee has encountered huge incarceration rates and resultant severe prison
overcrowding. The fact that a State locks up so many of its citizens cannot be convincingly
explained away by a high crime rate; the general outlook of members of the law enforcement
agencies and the judiciary must, in part, be responsible.
In such circumstances, throwing increasing amounts of money at the prison estate
will not offer a solution. Instead, current law and practice in relation to custody pending trial
and sentencing as well as the range of non-custodial sentences available need to be reviewed.
This is precisely the approach advocated in Committee of Ministers Recommendation N° R
(99) 22 on prison overcrowding and prison population inflation. The CPT very much hopes
that the principles set out in that important text will indeed be applied by member States; the
implementation of this Recommendation deserves to be closely monitored by the Council of
Europe.
Large capacity dormitories
29.
In a number of countries visited by the CPT, particularly in central and eastern
Europe, inmate accommodation often consists of large capacity dormitories which contain all
or most of the facilities used by prisoners on a daily basis, such as sleeping and living areas as
well as sanitary facilities. The CPT has objections to the very principle of such
accommodation arrangements in closed prisons and those objections are reinforced when, as
is frequently the case, the dormitories in question are found to hold prisoners under extremely
cramped and insalubrious conditions. No doubt, various factors - including those of a cultural
nature - can make it preferable in certain countries to provide multi-occupancy
accommodation for prisoners rather than individual cells. However, there is little to be said in
favour of - and a lot to be said against - arrangements under which tens of prisoners live and
sleep together in the same dormitory.
1
2nd General Report - CPT/Inf (92) 3, paragraph 4, and 7th General Report - CPT/Inf (97) 10,
paragraphs 12-15.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents