A/HRC/4/33/Add.1
Page 34
Para
17.
Country
Bhutan
Date
12/07/06
Type
JUA
Mandate
WGAD;
FRDX;
RINT;
TOR;
Allegations transmitted
Government Response
Two Christians, John Tamang (alias Purna
Bahadur Tamang) and Benjamin Sharma (alias
Budhu Mani Dhungana) in the town of Paro. On
7 January 2006, they were arrested for screening
the film ‘Jesus’ in the town of Paro. The arrest
was carried out by an officer of the Crime and
Investigation Department in Thimphu, who
punched and hit the two men during the arrest.
They are thought to be being held incommunicado
in Thimphu and have been subjected to torture
immediately isolated in the facility’s medical
centre and transferred to the national
tuberculosis hospital. Only persons cured of
tuberculosis and under regular medical
supervision may be held together with healthy
detainees. The accessibility of medical
assistance for detainees is at the same level
as for the country’s population as a whole.
The patient-doctor ratio for detainees is 53.1
per 10,000 (compared to 46.2 per 10,000 for
the country as a whole), the ratio of
paramedical and nursing staff is 98.1 per
10,000 detainees (compared to 119.7 per
10,000 for the country as a whole) and the
hospital bed rate is 439.4 per 10,000
(compared to 107.4 per 10,000 for the country
as a whole). Clothing allowances for detainees
are set by the Ministry of Internal Affairs and
nutritional standards by the Council of
Ministers. At the current time, work is under
way by the State authorities on the approval of
a draft government decision to raise the
nutritional standards.
By letter dated 27/07/06, the Government
reported that they were handed over to the
Royal Bhutan Police on 8 January 2006 by
villagers. They were produced before the
District Court in Paro on 9 January 2006. In
accordance with the due process of law, they
were charged in the District Court and found
guilty of several offences. Mr Dhungana and
Mr Tamang have thus been tried and
sentenced as per the law, in an open trial with
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents