JUSTICE FOR ALL
In contrast, within the Austrian system,
the converse is possible, and persons who
are declared criminally responsible may
receive a (regular) sentence in addition
to their (potentially unlimited) preventive
detention. In this case, the preventive
measures should be applied first, and the
prison sentence after. The time they spend
in preventive detention counts towards the
sentence. If they are released from the preventive detention before the end of their
sentence (if they have received one), they
are transferred into the “ordinary” prison.183
In practice, however, preventive detention
very often exceeds the prison sentence.
One of the reasons for this extended stay
is that during the preventive detention, the
person concerned often does not receive
the therapy needed in order to demonstrate
an improvement in their condition and
qualify for release, or therapies start very
late (see Section 2.6.8.1).184
All six partner countries provide for a
specific measure to respond to a detainee
in prison who is experiencing an acute
mental health condition, either because a
pre-existing condition worsens or because
they develop a severe mental health condition while imprisoned. In three countries
(Italy, Bulgaria and sometimes in Germany),
there is the option of providing psychiatric
care for detainees with acute mental
health issues in a specialised unit within
an ordinary prison, as well as the option of
either postponing the sentence for care in
the community or transferring detainees to
psychiatric facilities in the community for
treatment. Special mental health units in
prisons, such as the ATSMs (Articolazioni
per la tutela della salute mentale) in Italy,
have been criticised for their lack of a precise legal framework and little therapeutic
efficacy due to a lack of treatment options
and insufficient personnel.185 Another issue
with such specialised units is that they only
exist in selected prison facilities. For example, in Bulgaria, only in Sofia and Lovech
are there are specialised hospitals for active
treatment of prisoners at the prisons.186
In some countries (Austria, some states in
Germany) it is possible to transfer detainees with acute mental health conditions to
psychiatric departments of public hospitals
or use the inpatient structures of the civic
care system. However, in practice, arranging such transfers is not without difficulties
due to a lack of capacity of prison hospitals,
the lack of willingness of public hospitals
or need for further security staff for the
transfer/placement in a public hospital.
Moreover, in five of the partner countries
(Slovenia, Lithuania, Bulgaria, Austria,
and Germany) detainees who exhibit
acute mental health conditions may also
be (temporarily) transferred from prisons
to psychiatric institutions or places where
compulsory treatment measures are usually
executed and where persons who are determined to not be criminally responsible
are placed. In other words, it is still possible
for detainees with disabilities who are
serving a sentence of imprisonment in an
ordinary prison (because they have been
determined to have full or diminished criminal responsibility) to (temporarily) come
under a regime belonging to the “second
track” and under the purview of a security
measure. Thereby, the distinction between
persons who are deemed dangerous based
on intellectual and/or psychosocial disability, and therefore without criminal legal
capacity, and persons who are deemed to
have criminal legal capacity but develop an
acute “condition”, becomes blurred.
Such referrals to other institutions for
(compulsory) treatment are often short and,
according to experts, the quality of treatment and care provided is often low, as the
facilities may lack the necessary resources.
Afterwards, the person is then transferred
back to the prison, and it can happen, as
reported in Austria and Slovenia, that the
same prisoners can be transferred back and
forth between the prison and the forensic
psychiatry unit several times.187
57
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents