IMPLEMENTATION UNDER NATIONAL LAW
2.6.6. LACK OF SPECIALISED STAFF
A prominent finding across all six partner
countries and beyond has also been a lack of
specialised staff – medical staff, psychologists,
psychiatrists – in prisons as well as psychiatric
institutions.
For example, in one detention facility in
Austria, medical care was not available after
3:30 pm or on weekends. In another detention
facility, three psychiatrists were available for a
total of 22 hours per week for an estimated
800 detainees, more than 100 of which were in
preventive detention.244 Furthermore, experts
in Austria have reported that prisons (and also
special prison departments for persons with
intellectual and/or psychosocial disabilities)
do not have sufficient staff from the general
health field and still primarily depend on prison
staff (carrying weapons).245 This was also
confirmed by the latest CPT report in 2023.
The Bulgarian Ombudsman Institution, in its
2020 Annual report, noted that psychiatric
hospitals exhibited insufficient numbers of
doctors, nurses and paramedics, creating
conditions for untimely and low-quality
treatment of patients, as well as risk in terms
of monitoring and care for patients with
aggression and auto-aggression.246
In prisons, prison officers are usually not
trained to interact with persons with intellectual and/or psychosocial disabilities and are
not able to provide specialised care, also due
to constraints in staff time and resources. In
general, a shortage of people working in the
forensic field and in social work and related
fields has been reported in Slovenia and
other countries. It was reported during the
consultation workshops that in Croatia, to
alleviate the lack of support for persons with
disabilities in prisons, there are sometimes
paid assistants, who are fellow detainees and
assist them in their daily life.
In Slovenia, due to a shortage of psychiatrists
in prisons, detainees often have to wait a long
time to access psychiatric support, and it has
been observed that in the evening and on
weekends, the medicinal therapy, including
psychiatric, is not distributed by medical staff,
68
but prison guards.247 On the other hand, some
interviewed psychiatric experts reported
positive experiences regarding availability
and the quality of psychiatric care in prisons.
They also mentioned that the assessment
and referral mechanisms in place have led
to significant decreases in suicide rates in
Slovenian prisons in the last ten years.248
2.6.7. MONITORING, SAFEGUARDS
AND HAVING A VOICE
Experts have highlighted that NPMs and
monitoring bodies perform crucial tasks in
monitoring places of deprivation of liberty,
including where persons with intellectual and/
or psychosocial disabilities are held. However,
one challenge for NPMs that has been raised
was the many inconsistencies in international
standards, and a lack of guidance specifically
for monitoring the deprivation of liberty of
persons with intellectual and/or psychosocial
disabilities.
Furthermore, NPM visits can be limited in time
and scope, and their purpose is not to give a
voice to individual experiences. Experts have
raised the need to give detainees the opportunity to have their voice heard and share
their experiences of detention and grievances
beyond filing formal complaints. NGOs were
suggested as potentially suitable to fill that role
and to develop “living libraries” of persons with
intellectual and/or psychosocial disabilities
who experienced detention. External research
can also describe situations and analyse perspectives of persons concerned, but access to
institutions can be highly restricted.
Experts (including from Austria, Bulgaria
and Lithuania) have noted that persons
with intellectual and/or psychosocial disabilities – whether they are held in prison,
but particularly if they are in a compulsory
treatment regime – are often not aware of
the possibility to file a complaint. If they
are, individuals are often either not able to
access support to file a complaint or they
are discouraged from filing a complaint, as
this might be perceived as non-compliance
and draw negative repercussions (such as
the administration of additional medication,
as experts from Slovenia have noted).
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents