E/CN.4/1995/34/Add.1
page 6
Mr. Sergei Kovalev; the Deputy Minister of the Interior, Mr. Pyotr Mischenkov;
the Deputy Head of the Moscow Police, General Viktor Kononov; and the Deputy
at the Office of the Procurator General, Mr. Yuri Sherbanenko. The Special
Rapporteur also had informal discussions with the Deputy Minister of Foreign
Affairs, Mr. Sergei Lavrov, who hosted a luncheon for the Special Rapporteur.
13.
In St. Petersburg, the Special Rapporteur met with the First Deputy at
the Ministry of the Interior, Mr. Nikolai Gorbachevsky. He also held
discussions with Colonel Vladimir Spitznadel, the Deputy Head of Police and
Head of Services of Corrections and Social Rehabilitation, who coordinated,
and accompanied the Special Rapporteur during the visit to St. Petersburg,
Mr. Yuli Andreevitch Ribakov, a member of the State Duma from St. Petersburg,
escorted the Special Rapporteur during much of his visit there.
14.
The Special Rapporteur also visited places of detention in both Moscow
and St. Petersburg. In Moscow he visited the following locations: Butyrskaya
and Matrosskaya Tishnina No. 1, the two large remand centres for the city of
Moscow; the IVS at Petrovka 38, the headquarters of the Moscow Police, and at
police station No. 11; and City Hospital No. 20 where seriously ill or injured
detainees are taken to receive medical care. In St. Petersburg the Special
Rapporteur visited the following locations: the remand centres Kresty and
Lebedeva; the IVS at a Leningrad district police station; a strict regime
colony approximately 30 kilometres outside St. Petersburg in Fornosovo; and a
juvenile re-educational and labour colony in Kolpino.
15.
Within each of these detention centres the Special Rapporteur was able to
interview and receive testimony from detainees. It must be recorded, however,
that the Special Rapporteur was denied permission to speak in private with
detainees in the pre-trial detention centres due to a Russian law which
prohibits a pre-trial detainee from discussing his or her case with anyone
other than the investigator, an official of the Ministry of the Interior or
the Office of the Procurator, or his or her attorney. As a result, all
interviews with remand prisoners in pre-trial detention centres took place in
the presence of an official of the Ministry of the Interior. The Special
Rapporteur notes that the presence of this official may have deterred, and
indeed appeared to deter, the detainees from speaking freely about possible
abuses on the part of the police, prison staff, investigators or procurators.
16.
The Special Rapporteur would like to emphasize that the Russian
authorities made every effort to make his visit public and transparent. To
this end, they initiated media coverage of his visit. In particular, the
Department of International Humanitarian Cooperation and Human Rights arranged
for the Special Rapporteur’s interview with a St. Petersburg TV station and
his live interview with the radio station Echo of Moscow. On the final day of
his visit, the Ministry for Foreign Affairs arranged a press conference in the
press centre of the Ministry, which was covered by national television and
attended by Russian and foreign journalists as well as representatives of
Russian NGOs.
17.
In addition to meetings with government officials and visits to detention
centres, the Special Rapporteur also met and held discussions with
representatives of several non-governmental human rights organizations. In
particular, he held lengthy discussions with the Director of the Moscow