young children (from 10 months to 24 months old) who were living with their mothers in the prison and did not figure at all in the
official statistics, nor in budgetary provisions. The prison was reportedly built for 400 prisoners, and later extended. The director of
Cotonou Prison confirmed that there was no criterion for certifying the capacity of the prisons.
149.At Abomey Prison, the population at the time of the visit was reported as 1,105 prisoners. There were 1,035 male prisoners,
22 of them male adolescent detainees who were held in a separate unit; all female prisoners were housed in two parts of a separate
unit for women, with four female adolescent detainees among them, in addition to 10 babies and young children aged from 30 days
old to 4 years old. The prison was reportedly built in 1,950 for 200 prisoners, with ten buildings designed to house 20 prisoners
each. This level of occupancy was, according to the current director, never respected. The inner compound of the Prison was as a
result very cramped and detainees had little space available to exercise outside the buildings where they slept.
150.The SPT notes that the authorities intend to transfer all sentenced prisoners to the new prison opened in November
2007 in Akpro-Missérété, so that the remaining eight prisons are used for remand prisoners only. The delegation also
heard of plans to build more new prisons along the Akpro-Missérété Prison model. In this regard, the director of
Abomey Prison referred to a site having already been identified to house a new prison for 1,000 detainees. However,
prison building alone will not constitute, and should not be seen as, the sole solution to the current overcrowding.
151.Representatives of the Ministry of Justice informed the delegation that a number of steps have been taken to address the
overcrowding, including discussions on alternative measures to detention, particularly for adolescent detainees; use of the annual
presidential pardon; introduction of social rehabilitation activities to reduce the number of repeat offenders; and the drafting of a bill
on community work as an alternative to detention. The SPT encourages Benin’s for its efforts in this regard, and notes that article 118
of the Code of Criminal Procedure provides that preventive detention should be an exceptional measure.
152.The SPT notes that no information was provided on the availability of bail as an alternative to remand. Although bail
might be granted by the court, there could still be financial obstacles to achieving bail in practice. A number of detainees
in prisons complained about the very high amounts imposed by the judge for bail. This may be a factor contributing to the
population remanded in custody. The SPT requests information on whether and how an individual ’ s financial situation
might be taken into account in the setting of bail, the number of persons granted bail in 2007, and the number of persons
who, despite being granted bail, were unable to be released because they were unable to pay the amount. The SPT
invites the authorities to ensure observance of the principle that release on bail should be the rule, and remand custody
the exception and to consider the introduction of legal time limits for proceeding to trial.
153. The SPT recommends that a concerted strategy be adopted by the authorities to reduce the prison population
through a combination of measures, including:
(a) Conducting a thorough review of bottlenecks in criminal procedures before the various instances, in order to identify
gaps in resources and structural reasons for delays;
(b) Increasing communication and cooperation between the courts and the prisons to minimize delays in transmitting
judgments and orders, and in particular release orders, to ensure that persons are released as soon as the courts so
orders;
(c) Use of non-custodial measures for children, in accordance with Order No. 69-23 of 10 July 1989 relating to judgments
of crimes committed by minors;
(d) Diversion from custody of persons charged with petty offences through the use of other measures (such as caution) or
a fine proportionate to the financial means of the individual person;
(e) Reduction in the number of people remanded in custody through the use of conditional release (liberté proviso ire) in
accordance with article 120 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (with or without bail), and article 358 of the Code of
Criminal Procedure;
(f) Respecting legal times for dealing with cases provided for in the Code of Criminal Procedure;
(g) Release of all remand prisoners who have already been in custody for longer than the maximum prison sentence
imposable for the offence of which they stand accused;
(h) Reduction of the sentenced population through the imposition of community penalties, reparation and restitution;
(i) Increase in the use of the régime de semi-liberté in accordance with article 574 of the Code of Criminal Procedure;
(j) Increase in the use of release on license/parole ( liberté conditionelle ) in accordance with article 580 of the Code of
Criminal Procedure (conditional release of sentenced prisoners meeting risk assessment criteria); and
(k) Commutation of all death sentences so that there is a possibility of review and eventual release.
(a)Remand prisoners
154.According to article 570 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, remand prisoners in Benin can be detained in prisons where
sentenced prisoners are serving their sentence. However, they should be detained separately from sentenced prisoners and, if
possible, detained in individual cells. The separation between prévenus/inculpés and sentenced prisoners is also provided for in
article 15 of Decree No. 73-293. As will be detailed below, there was no such separation in the two prisons to which the delegation
paid full visits.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents