National Preventive Mechanism
Commission 1 observed that practice in Innsbruck Regional Hospital and in
Rankweil Regional Hospital does not comply with this legal provision. For
example, notifications were not submitted at the weekend but on the next
workday.
The owners or operators of the medical facilities contacted by the NPM have
since stated that they are willing to guarantee the compulsory immediate
reporting of measures that restrict freedom as stipulated in the Hospitalisation
of Mentally Ill Persons Act by implementing organisational measures.
On a visit to the University Clinic for Child and Adolescent Psychiatry in
Vienna, Commission 4 observed that in September and October 2016 the
private clothes of more than 60% of the resident patients were taken away for
two to ten days. The minors were only allowed to wear thin cotton hospital
pyjamas with buttons on the front during this phase. Only underpants were
allowed whereas it was forbidden to wear a t-shirt or a bra, to the frustration of
the girls affected. The Commission saw this as an impermissible restriction of
personal rights and violation of the United Nations Convention on the Rights
of the Child. Pursuant to Section 34a of the Hospitalisation of Mentally Ill
Persons Act, the right to wear private clothes may only be restricted if this is
necessary to avert danger according to Section 3 (1) or to protect the rights of
other persons in the psychiatric ward, and if it is proportionate to the purpose
of the measure. A corresponding notification obligation is not expressly
required in Section 34a of the Hospitalisation Act. However, expert opinion
says that this can be derived directly from the general protection mandate
stipulated in Section 1 (1) of the Hospitalisation Act. If this were not the case,
the patient advocacy would be unable to exercise their right to file proceedings
for the protection of privacy.
XX
Measures that restrict freedom must be submitted and confirmed immediately, including on
public holidays and weekends.
XX
The ban on wearing private clothes is a violation of personal rights, and therefore the
patients’ representatives must be informed immediately.
5.2.5
Application of measures that restrict freedom
Measures that restrict freedom are only permissible if they are applied to avert
danger, that is, to avert a serious or considerable danger to the life or health of
the patient or others, if they support medical treatment or care, and if they are
not inappropriate. A measure that restricts freedom can thus not be justified
with organisational, personal or business-related reasons.
Measures that restrict
freedom as a last resort
129
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents