Tools of Torture and Repression in South America
Projectiles of varying sizes can be fired using the same calibre ammunition, e.g. a 40mm cartridge
could contain one large projectile or dozens of small projectiles.
While compiling this report, Omega came across numerous reports of the abusive use of kinetic impact
projectiles against people exercising their right to peaceful assembly throughout the region.
Furthermore, a number of local human rights defenders and civil society organisations consulted
identified this as one of their key concerns regarding the abusive use of law enforcement equipment
in their respective countries.
Illustrative country examples of excessive use of force with kinetic impact projectiles
Venezuela: In 2014, there were several reports of inappropriate use of kinetic impact
projectiles by Venezuelan law enforcement officials. As well as using rubber bullets in
enclosed spaces, law enforcement officials fired rubber bullets which hit youths in the eyes
in protests in Táchira and Carabobo States, one of whom later died from his injuries.50 In
addition, it is reported that post-electoral protests in 2013 were met with excessive force
including several instances of protesters being shot in the back with rubber bullets. On one
occasion a fleeing protester fell and was shot in the legs at point-blank range for ‘running
away and protesting against the government’.51
Argentina: The use of rubber ammunition to disperse protests, in violation of the Minimum
Criteria for the Conduct of Police Bodies and Security Forces in Public Demonstrations,52 has
been highlighted as an issue of particular concern. On 22 October 2014, the national
Gendarmerie shot rubber ammunition at a group of workers protesting against their
dismissals by an auto parts factory. Over 50 people were injured by the rubber ammunition,
five of them seriously, and it was alleged that the Gendarmerie continued shooting at
workers as they fled.53 Subsequently, a San Isidro Federal Court judge ordered that the
Gendarmerie be replaced in further operations connected with this labour dispute by
another law enforcement agency ‘with the capacity for dialogue and restraint in order to
avoid future escalations of violence’.54
Brazil: Law enforcement officials in Brazil have reportedly used rubber bullets to repress
peaceful protests. The IACHR expressed concern over the excessive use of force in June 2013,
particularly with regard to the targeting of journalists covering protests in São Paulo.
Journalists Fábio Braga, Giuliana Vallone and Sérgio Silva were reportedly hit in the face with
50
Amnesty International, Amnesty International Report 2014/15: The State of the World’s Human Rights, pp.
401-402.
51
COFAVIC, Informe situación de Derechos Humanos en Venezuela en el contexto post electoral de abril de
2013, pp. 25-26.
52
Argentinian Ministry of Security, ‘Criterios Mínimos sobre la Actuación de los Cuerpos Policiales Fuerzas de
Seguridad en Manifestaciones Públicas’, published in: Los Nuevos Paradígmas del Ministerio de Seguridad y el
Consenso Federal,
<http://www.minseg.gob.ar/sites/default/files/Publicaciones/Los%20Nuevos%20Paradigmas%20del%20Minist
erio%20de%20Seguridad%20y%20el%20Consenso%20Federal.pdf> [accessed 31 May 2016].
53
CELS, Derechos humanos en Argentina: Informe 2015, pp. 299, 303
54
Sandra Arroyo Salgado, ‘Hay cortes que se convalidan y que son acompañados por las fuerzas de seguridad y
otros no,’ La Nación, 5 November 2014, <http://www.lanacion.com.ar/1741436-una-jueza-ordeno-retirar-a-lagendarmeria-de-los-operativos-antipiquete-en-panamericana> [accessed 31 May 2016].
17
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents