Advance unedited version CCPR/C/132/D/2615/2015
in particular the Manual on the Effective Investigation and Documentation of Torture and
Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment (Istanbul Protocol) and the
Guidelines for Medico-Legal Care for Victims of Sexual Violence issued by the World
Health Organization; e) provide training and educational courses to members of the judiciary,
police and the health sector on the diligent investigation of cases of sexual abuse of women,
including a gender and ethnicity perspective; and f) offer educational programmes to the
Istanbul Protocol, international human rights law and international humanitarian law for the
judiciary, army, security forces and all persons who may be involved in dealing with persons
deprived of their liberty.
State party’s observations on admissibility and merits
4.1
In its observations dated 4 September 2015,
communication is inadmissible because the author has
that are available both through the criminal justice
mechanism. The latter mechanism is the appropriate
committed during the armed conflict.
the State party considers that the
failed to exhaust domestic remedies
system and the transitional justice
means for truth-seeking for crimes
4.2
With respect to the ordinary criminal justice system, the author’s writ of mandamus is
still pending before the Supreme Court of Nepal and, according to article 107 of the Interim
Constitution of Nepal, the Supreme Court may issue an appropriate order to provide full
justice to a writ petitioner. In addition, domestic legislation may provide specific statutes of
limitations to file first information reports, depending on the nature of the case.
4.3
With respect to the transitional justice system, the author may file a complaint before
the Truth and Reconciliation Commission, which was established pursuant to the Act on the
Commission on Investigation of Enforced Disappearance, Truth and Reconciliation of 2014.
The objectives of that Act are to ensure and provide truth, justice, reparations, and public
acknowledgement of victims; prevent abuse; and combat impunity. Section 26 of the Act
expressly prohibits amnesty to conflict related rapes and other serious violations of human
rights. Established in 2015, the Truth and Reconciliation Commission is mandated to
investigate human rights violations related to the conflict; recommend that the Government
prosecute alleged offenders, and provide reparation and justice to victims.18 The Commission
has drafted its governing Regulation and is currently engaged with developing its Terms of
Reference. In order to inform how the Commission will approach its mandate, its
Commissioners have visited 20 districts and have held discussions with victims of the conflict,
civil society members, rights defenders, government officials and other stakeholders.
4.4
The State party is committed to conducting prompt and impartial investigations and
bringing perpetrators of sexual violence to justice. Offences related to sexual violence,
including rape, violence against women and torture, are criminalized under domestic law. No
one is immune to prosecution for crimes of sexual violence. Individuals convicted of rape
may be imprisoned for up to 16 years. When an individual files a first information report with
the relevant investigating authority regarding an offence related to sexual violence, that
authority is legally required to conduct an investigation. To enhance access to justice for
victims of rape, parliamentary legislative committees approved an amendment bill proposing
to extend to six months the 35-day statute of limitations period for filing a complaint about
rape. In addition, the legislative Parliament is currently considering a new bill proposing to
fully criminalize all forms of torture and ill-treatment, pursuant to the Convention against
Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment.
4.5
The ordinary justice system does not suffice for truth-seeking, prosecution of
perpetrators, reparations or rehabilitation to victims. Truth-seeking is at the core of
transitional justice mechanisms, which is used to identify perpetrators and victims, and to
document patterns of abuses for institutional reform. It should be noted that truth-seeking
takes place after the establishment of an officially-sanctioned truth commission or
commission of inquiry that is authorized to investigate the past. Judicial proceeding against
18
The State party also notes that in 2015, the Commission on Investigation of Enforced Disappearance
was also created, and considers that the two Commissions represent a significant step forward for
Nepal’s transitional justice process.
7