and socially-invalidating pathologies; on the other hand, as far as prisons are concerned, autonomy appears to be
a concern which is diametrically opposed, in most cases, to a mode of operation characterised by total subjection
of the prisoner during their incarceration.
The architecture of places of deprivation of liberty should promote personal
autonomy, as far as the practical facilities thereof are concerned, and in
terms of modes of access to external spaces.
2.2.1 Enabling Persons to Take Practical Responsibility for Themselves
During periods in which they are temporarily deprived of their liberty, persons should not lose
the habit of carrying out the day-to-day actions that they have to complete when they are free:
getting up on time, cooking, washing, hanging out and ironing their linen, doing their shopping
etc.
Architectural design enabling people to wash their personal linen and to
prepare and share meals contributes thereto, at the same time as
contributing to their physical well-being, psychological balance and
autonomy.
This familiarisation with the demands of daily life, which is necessary for adults, involves
a real learning process for most minors placed in CEFs, which constitutes an essential
component of their education and supervision in these centres. Mastery of these simple actions,
ensured in appropriate premises for adults, is in itself likely to make release easier and prevent
recidivism. Moreover certain CEFs illustrate this concern by having a unit for preparation for
ordinary life, a kind of studio flat where young people are able to learn the rudiments of
independent daily life.
The system of “prison shops” organises the sale, distribution and payment for food
products and various different items, which are available for purchase on terms that only leave a
limited share of autonomy to the buyer: all the latter has to do is fill in an order form, and wait
for distribution of the item, which is generally delivered to their cell, the corresponding sum of
money being debited from their personal account without any action on their part. Apart from
the difficulty of understanding the system and filling in the order form in writing for a portion of
the prison population, which is unable (or barely able) to read and write in French, this mode of
organisation gives rise to problems of operation and incomprehension, which constitute one of
the recurring grounds for recriminations in prisons. The principle points of dispute are of two
kinds: they arise from the fact that delivery in most cases takes place in the cell, in the absence of
the purchaser, who thus cannot immediately check whether the order has been fulfilled, and from
the difficulty of checking their purchases on the bank statements drawn up by the administration.
After the model of the cafeterias which exist in certain mental health institutions, penal
institutions should make provision for premises – judiciously located for ease of access –
enabling prisoners to go to a shop or minimarket, in order to choose and order their
purchases directly, pay for them using a magnetic card type system and receive immediate
delivery. This type of outlet could also enable direct access by means of an automatic pay
point for certain services.
In all places of deprivation of ability where persons stay on a long-term basis, returned to
autonomy or maintenance thereof therefore makes it necessary to make premises available,
such as a kitchen, laundry room and shop.
Upstream from any new building and from the renovation of any existing buildings, the
question of the location of the premises provided for cooking and doing the laundry and
shopping, needs to be posed in relation to accommodation areas, classrooms and rooms for
144
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents