The NPM finds it worrying that there are no regular reviews of
the state of patient health in the special medical facility by
visiting physicians. Rather, the detainees being held there must
actively request to be seen by a physician. The attitude of the
medical and nursing staff observed by the commission has led
to the conclusion that – in the NPM’s opinion – they have a
highly dubious understanding of what nursing entails.
No visits
Regarding the criticism of the nursing measures and the medical
and therapeutic care, the Federal Ministry of Justice referred the
final report of the working group on “reorganisation of the
special medical facility”, which was deployed in December 2014
and led by the (former) prison administration. The final report
submitted in mid-2015 confirms the need for action and
improvement with respect to the medical, nursing and hygienic
conditions of the special medical facility as had been reported
by the NPM. Based on this information, the Federal Ministry of
Justice is currently deciding whether the Stein special medical
facility should retain its license under the law governing special
medical facilities.
Working group
confirms NPM’s
concerns
In the meantime, personnel changes were labelled as
emergency measures. The heads of the medical and nursing
services were replaced. A hygiene manager was appointed. It is
gratifying that two additional physicians (11 to 14 and 8 hours per
week) will provide service in the out-patient clinic and the special
medical facility of the Stein correctional institution.
Ministry reacts to
criticism by the NPM
Moreover, a strict separation between daytime and night-time
physicians ensured a more efficient allocation of responsibilities.
Under the new duty roster, a third nurse is now available in the
ward area of the special medical facility. In addition, according
to the Ministry, physicians now carried out daily visits in the
special medical facility and in some departments with closed
detention. A reorganisation of the nursing service has also been
promised.
Daily physician’s visits
The Federal Ministry of Justice did not agree with the
observations of the commission with respect to the individual
cases described. It pointed out that patients are generally
offered assistance by the nursing staff. They attempt to avoid
hospitalisation and to maintain and foster independence.
The NPM sees the emergency measures taken and the
additional measures promised as positive development.
However, the current improvements are still inadequate. It
would be desirable to implement additional measures as quickly
as possible in order to bring the special medical facility at the
Stein correctional institution up to standard and guarantee
adequate medical care.
Demands remain in
force
Moreover, the NPM emphasises that placebo medication can
only be tolerated if the patient is informed.
101
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents