37
Selected topics from 2020
serious mental health challenges. At the same
time, it is not always the case that admission
to mental healthcare is the better solution for
adolescents. A stay at a child welfare institution
with secure frameworks and stable personnel can
be better than a brief admission to hospital where
personnel work a three-shift pattern.
However, this requires active follow-up from spe
cialist health services with outpatient and advisory
functions to ensure correct evaluation, treatment
and optimal care for the adolescent. Specialist
health services may experience that the needs
of the young person are safeguarded by the child
welfare services; however, they may not be aware
that this is often with the use of intrusive coercion
and control. They can also be unaware of other
aspects of adolescent’s stay at the institution,
for instance that the adolescent may live isolated
from their peers or that a lack of stability among
personnel can lead to insecurity. In some cases,
a long time has passed without any initiation of
cooperation between the institution and specialist
health services.23
Weak legal safeguards for children who
live alone
In total, our findings indicate that children and
adolescents who were placed alone in an institu
tion with staff only, can be subjected to intrusive
interventions that in some cases can amount to
violations of their rights.
In a report concerning children who live in child
welfare institutions, the Ombudsperson for Chil
dren describes many of the same risk factors we
have observed during our visits, and recommends
improved analysis and evaluation of children’s
needs, in advance of their placement in an institu
tion.24 In a survey carried out by the Office of the
Auditor General of Norway, one of the principal
findings was that the needs of several children
were not adequately evaluated when selecting
an institution.25 The Norwegian Board of Health
Supervision’s report “Omsorg og rammer. Når barn
trenger mer [Care and frameworks. When children
need more] highlights some of the problematic
aspects of separate placements of children.26
When children and adolescents live alone with
staff, they become dependent on them in a way
that can present challenges to legal safeguards.
An example from one of our visits illustrates
this: An adolescent was placed alone in a remote
institution; a mobile telephone had been confiscat
ed and no schooling arrangements had yet been
made. The adolescent therefore had extremely
limited opportunity to contact others. If the adoles
cent wished to speak to a legal representative or to
supervisory bodies such as the County Governor or
The Parliamentary Ombudsman, a member of staff
would hold the telephone while the adolescent was
using it.27 This situation removed most opportuni
ties from the adolescent to report unlawful issues
or risk of violations.
On the basis of the challenges that the Parliamen
tary Ombudsman has thus far found in relation to
children who live alone with staff in child welfare
institutions, the Ombudsman believes it is likely
that there will be a need to carry out several more
visits to this type of institution.
23 See report from Norwegian Board of Health Supervision (9/2019). “Omsorg og rammer. Når barn trenger mer», where similar
findings are also described in a review of cases with extremely serious consequences. See page 13.
24 Ombudsperson for Children (2020). “De tror vi er shitkids.” [They call us shitkids] Report on children who live in child welfare
institutions.
25 Office of the Auditor General of Norway (2020). Document 3:7 (2019–2020). “Investigation into whether state child welfare
authorities ensure the best for children in child welfare institutions” page 52.
26 Report from Norwegian Board of Health Supervision (9/2019). “Omsorg og rammer. Når barn trenger mer [Care and frameworks.
When children need more]”
27 See the Parliamentary Ombudsman's report after visit to Stendi Nymogården, 12–14 November 2019.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents