E/CN.4/1994/31
page 103
of the forces which took part in the arrest were requested to make statements
before Magistrate No. 8. No charges had, however, been brought against any
particular agent. The contents of the medical reports were not known.
487. On the other hand, the Government also provided the Special Rapporteur
with a copy of a report sent to Magistrate No. 8 by the Chief Attorney of
Bilbao indicating the circumstances in which Mr. Urra was arrested. The
report also indicated that representatives of judicial authorities who visited
Mr. Urra at the Basurto hospital on 30 January 1992 found that he was in a
situation of total disorientation and that he bore multiple injuries and
bruises of recent origin. A few hours later a nurse who was urgently called
to Mr. Urra’s room, found there two men who identified themselves as members
of the Civil Guard and saw that the detainee had blood in his mouth. He was
subsequently examined by a forensic physician who also found multiple injuries
and bruises. When asked about their origin the detainee gave a full account
of the treatment to which he had been subjected, including beatings,
suffocation and death threats. He indicated that the ill-treatment had
continued at the hospital. A copy of the medical report containing all the
details of Mr. Urra’s state of health was also provided by the Government.
488. Manuel Muiños García, an inmate at Puerto-2 prison, Cádiz, was reported
to have been brutally beaten on 14 August 1992 by prison officials who tried
to tie him to his bed, apparently as a punishment for having insulted them.
As a result of this assault Manuel Muiños reportedly suffered a broken nose
and split lips, and one of his eyes was totally closed by swelling. In this
state, he allegedly remained tied to his bed for several hours before he was
seen by a doctor. On the following day he was transferred to Valencia prison.
A claim of ill-treatment was lodged with the Prison Inspection Judge of
Valencia.
489. With respect to this case the Government provided a report issued by the
"Dirección General de Instituciones Penitenciarias" indicating that Mr. Muiños
had attacked several members of the prison staff. As a result of the struggle
which followed four agents as well as the prisoner had had to be taken care of
at the prison’s medical service for slight injuries.
490. Eduardo Basabe Larrinaga and Germán Cristóbal Aznar were reportedly
beaten severely during their transfer from Ocaña 1 prison in Cuenca to
Nanclares de Oca prison in Alava by the Civil Guards responsible for escorting
them on 17 August 1992. The family lodged a complaint with the court of
Gasteiz on 27 August 1992.
491. Pako Etxebeste Arozena, an inmate at the provincial prison of
Martutene-Donostia, was reported to have been severely beaten during his
transfer from Burgos prison on 18 August 1992, as a result of which he
suffered injuries to one eye and to the jaw area, and multiple bruises to the
head. The family filed a complaint with Court of Investigation No. 2 at
San Sebastián on 19 October 1992.
492. Regarding the above three cases the Government forwarded a report made by
the 111 post of the Civil Guard indicating that judicial authorities had
requested information about the identity of the agents who took part in the
said transfers and had questioned some of them. However, nobody had been
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents