If a person is fearful of flying, there should be a medical report, including the prescribed
medicines.
If a person being removed or deported is chronically ill, the authorities in the target country
should be informed of the person’s medical needs if there is a legal basis for doing so.
A sufficient amount of baby food must be made available.
Good conduct of interviews with due regard for the situation should be standardised.
Professional interpreters should be used during (forced) returns.
2.7.2.2
Role conflicts of the Association of Human Rights Austria
As one of its last recommendations (June 2012), the former Human
Rights Advisory Board of the Federal Ministry of the Interior suggested
that the Association of Human Rights Austria (Verein Menschenrechte
Österreich) should not be entrusted to be the sole contractor in the
capacity of human rights observer. Moreover, conflicting roles for the
Association of Human Rights Austria as human rights observer,
interpreter and return counsellor should be avoided.
It was upon the recommendation of the commissions, that the AOB
initiated ex-officio investigative proceedings in early 2013. The question
was whether the Federal Ministry of the Interior should also hire
additional organisations as human rights observers in the future. The
Federal Ministry of the Interior said it had accepted the proposal of the
former Human Rights Advisory Board of the Federal Ministry of the
Interior. Accordingly, the Ministry was already discussing activities as
future human rights observers with other NGOs. The Federal Ministry
of the Interior said it intended to rotate various NGOs as human rights
observers. However, no decision had been made in this regard by the
end of 2014.
Human rights observers
In addition, the NPM criticised the Association of Human Rights Austria
in its capacity as interpreter in many cases. This related to the quality
of the interpreting services as well as the risk of role conflicts if the
organisation functioned both as interpreter and return counsellor. Thus
the commissions observed, for example, that, in the course of contact
meetings, employees of the Association of Human Rights Austria
attempted to “convince” persons being deported to cooperate with
police and not resist the forced return.
Role conflicts of the
Association of Human
Rights Austria
The NPM is of the opinion – as was the former Human Rights Advisory
Board of the Federal Ministry of the Interior – that combining various
functions in a single entity inexorably leads to role conflicts because
the underlying interests and goals of the functions are different. While
(social) support during forced return or detention pending forced
return is typically based on a relationship of trust with the person
being supported, the activities of a professional interpreter must be
strictly objective and must proceed from a position that is independent
140
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents