Recommendations
(E/CN.4/2006/6/Add.3)
Situation during visit
(See: E/CN.4/2006/6/Add.3)
(b) Judges and prosecutors
Not in place.
routinely ask persons brought
from police custody how they
have been treated, and even in
the absence of a formal
complaint from the defendant,
order an independent medical
examination.
Steps taken in previous years
(See: A/HRC/4/33/Add.2,
A/HRC/7/3/Add.2 and
A/HRC/16/52/Add.2)
Information received in the reporting
period
Assistance (MCLA) and in the prisons, are
refereed to repeatedly in connection with
ill-treatment of prisoners.
Despite prisoners‘ complaints alleging
torture and inhuman or degrading
treatment, criminal cases are reportedly
launched under Art. 333 of the Criminal
Code (CC) (exceeding official powers)
instead of Article 144.1 (torture) and Art.
144.3 (inhuman or degrading treatment) of
the CC.
Non-governmental sources: The newly
CPC para. 73(f) states that a medical
examination is an absolute right that can introduced adversarial system has
reportedly brought about an increased
neither be denied nor restricted. Article
73(f) refers to medical expertise (needed indifference of the judiciary vis-à-vis
for the determination of important factual complaints or signs of ill-treatment of
circumstances of a case), which is subject defendants before court.
Reportedly, there were deficiencies both in
to a court decision;
law and in practice regarding the crucial
Article 922 of the Law on Imprisonment role of the judiciary in combating torture,
including in relation to shifting the burden
of 23 June 2005 requires a medical
of proof and the inadmissibility of
examination after every transfer;
evidence obtained by torture.
65
Internal Guidelines of the Prosecutor
General regarding Preliminary
Investigation into allegations of torture,
inhuman and degrading treatment of 7
Under the current legal system, full
medical examinations are reportedly no
longer mandatory at the time of entry to
the penitentiary but only take place upon
request; persons entering prison are only
screened for obvious injuries or diseases.
The medical staff at prisons is employed
by the MCLA and is reportedly under
considerable pressure of the prison
administration; thus, their ability to do
their work independently is seriously
challenged.
A/HRC/19/61/Add.3
CPC article 263, provides that, if
information recorded upon routine
medical examination shows that a
prisoner has injuries, the prosecutor can
initiate a preliminary investigation, even
in the absence of allegations from the
detainee;
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents