Long-term deprivation of liberty
120. In most of the prisons inspected in 2011, the CCTV surveillance system
did not meet the criterion set out in Paragraphs 334 and 477 of the Annual Report 2010, which advised extending these technical resources to all establishments in which there may be people deprived of liberty, except for cells and
sanitary facilities. In Albolote (Granada), for example, there are serious deficiencies and considerable deterioration in the system, due to its age and the fact that
it has not been upgraded. In Alcala de Guadaíra (Seville), the existing CCTV
surveillance system is obsolete and is not used. At Barcelona prison CCTV systems are only in place in the open section, where footage is not recorded, and in
the solitary confinement cells. At Castellón de la Plana, the system only covers
the common areas in the modules; it is very old, and the images are blurred and
in black and white; At Figueres (Girona), some cameras have blind angles, and
only some of them record footage. At Fontcalent psychiatric prison hospital (Alicante) there is no CCTV surveillance in some common areas. It is also lacking
from some of the cells in the acute care department and nearly all the infirmary
department. At Melilla the system only covers the yards and inter-modular corridors; At Tenerife II prison there is no video-surveillance system whatsoever.
The SGIP reports that a study was made of the cost of meeting the recommendations of the Ombudsman’s office and that for the time being it is not possible to
go ahead with the improvements, due to budgetary shortages, within the priorities established by prison authorities. However, in the specific case of Albolote
(Granada), it reports that it is currently examining the characteristics of the system, the needs for modernisation and recording and storage protocol. The Office
of the Catalan Justice Department has told us that in view of the imminent
opening of the new Puig de les Basses prison in Figueres (Girona), it is not considered necessary to make any investments in this section, given that the new
facility will meet all criteria on CCTV surveillance. Nonetheless, the necessary
measures have been taken to regulate the recording and storage of images showing any incident with an inmate.
The SGIP reports that it has
costed implementation of
the recommendations of
the Ombudsman’s Office
but budgetary restrictions
prevent them from being
implemented in their
entirety
CCTV surveillance system
at Alcala de Guadaíra
Photo 49
prison (Seville)
THE OMBUDSMAN OF SPAIN
143
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents