46
Legal Digest of International Fair Trial Rights
income from property, thus leading to violation of Article 6.154 In Ciorap v Moldova, a case
of a prisoner complaining of the alleged damage to his health caused by the actions of the
authorities, the Court found that, regardless of his ability to pay, the applicant should have
been exempted from paying court fees due to the nature of his claim.155
Practical obstacles to access by parties to the proceedings might also arise for the same sorts
of reasons that the public encounters in the context of obstacles to a public hearing (See
also 4.2). Parties may be prevented from accessing the judicial system, for example, because
of a lack of information regarding the place and time of hearing (See also 4.2.1 and 6.5.3) or
because the location of the court is such that it is difficult or impossible for parties to get to
the hearing venue (See also 4.2.2). Practical obstacles to access might also arise as a result of
a lack of facilities to allow physical access by disabled persons, although case law on this subject has been extremely hesitant.156 Articles 5(3) and 9 of the International Convention on
the Protection and Promotion of the Rights and Dignity of Persons with Disabilities obligate
States parties to make a “reasonable accommodation” to allow persons with disabilities to
access facilities and services available to others, requiring necessary and appropriate modifications and adjustments that do not impose a disproportionate or undue burden on the State.
2.2 Equality before courts and tribunals
Whereas equality of arms (See also 6.1) pertains to the enjoyment of procedural rights
between parties to the same proceeding, equal treatment is broader in its application and
engages the principles of equality before the law and non-discrimination. In its most simple
sense, equality before courts and tribunals involves the idea that everyone should be treated
the same.
As well as the reference in Article 14(1) of the ICCPR that “[a]ll persons shall be equal before
the courts and tribunals”, Article 16 guarantees that: “Everyone shall have the right to recognition everywhere as a person before the law.” Article 26 adds that “All persons are equal
before the law and are entitled without any discrimination to the equal protection of the
law…”157 Article 3 provides that the parties to the ICCPR “undertake to ensure the equal
right of men and women to the enjoyment of all civil and political rights set forth in the
present Covenant”. Article 14 of the ECHR similarly provides that the enjoyment of rights
must be secured without discrimination on any grounds. Protocol 12 to the ECHR refers,
in its preamble, to the principles of equality before the law and the entitlement to the equal
protection of the law as fundamental principles. Article 1 of Protocol 12 guarantees that:
154 Weissman and Others v Romania [2006] ECHR, paras 40, 42.
155 Ciorap v Moldova [2007] ECHR 502, para 95.
156 Loukis G. Loucaides, “The European Convention on Human Rights and the rights of persons with disabilities”, in The European Convention on Human Rights: Collected Essays (Martinus Nijhoff Publishers,
2008), p.5; Farcas v Romania [2010] ECHR, paras 48–49 available in French only.
157 UN Human Rights Committee, CCPR General Comment 32 (2007), para 65.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents