CAT/C/61/D/661/2015
questioned, as a suspect and as a defendant, he confessed to committing the theft and
selling the proceeds to someone he knew, O.R. As a result, Mr. Rakishev was released on
his own recognizance and was asked not to leave his area of residence, and to report to the
police if needed.
4.6
On 21 February 2011, Dmitry Rakishev’s case file was sent to the Stepnogorsk City
Court for trial hearings. Mr. Rakishev was summoned for these hearings multiple times, but
failed to appear. Because of Mr. Rakishev’s failure to appear, the court decided to remand
him to detention, once he was arrested. On 29 April, Dmitry Rakishev was found and
arrested and placed in a detention centre in the city of Stepnogorsk.
4.7
On 8 May 2011, the doctors of the ambulance confirmed the death of Dmitry
Rakishev. On the basis of autopsy results issued on 9 June, the cause of death was
identified as stage 2 subcutaneous fibrinogen pneumonia, which, in turn, caused general
intoxication in the body and acute pulmonary heart failure.
4.8
Also, experts identified various injuries on the body of the deceased: bruises under
the left eye and on the right shoulder and haemorrhages in soft tissues of the left frontal
area, right frontal parietal area and left parietal area of the head, which could have been
caused by the impact of a blunt object or objects, possibly 8-15 days before death. These
injuries could not have caused death and were considered to be “light bodily injuries”. It
was also ascertained that ribs 7 and 8 had been broken, possibly two to three weeks before
death; these were considered “moderate bodily injuries” and could not have caused death.
4.9
In addition, autopsy results revealed psoriasis, phlegmon of the soft tissues of the
cheek-mandibular area of the face, small-focal and perivascular cardiosclerosis, lumpystage coronarosclerosis, subtotal fatty liver, chronic hepatitis and focal nephrosclerosis, all
of which did directly cause the death of Dmitry Rakishev.
4.10 At the request of the relatives of Dmitry Rakishev, another medical forensic
examination was ordered on 11 May 2011.2
4.11 The State party further submits that on 27 June 2011, the Stepnogorsk police
initiated a criminal investigation into the injuries identified on the complainant’s body,
based on article 104 (1) of the Criminal Code.3
4.12 The records indicate that when first detained in the detention centre in Stepnogorsk,
Mr. Rakishev was examined by a paramedic, O.T. On 25 July 2011, O.T. was questioned,
and testified that she had indeed identified some injuries on Mr. Rakishev’s body when he
was admitted to the detention centre. Mr. Rakishev explained that several days earlier he
had been involved in a fight (without providing any details), which caused the injuries. The
relevant entry was made in the medical records at the detention centre.
4.13 On 4 May 2011, Mr. Rakishev complained of chest pain and an ambulance was
called. O.T. reported that he told her that on 29 or 30 April 2011, he had fallen from the
upper bunk in his cell. The next day, in the morning, Mr. Rakishev was taken to
Stepnogorsk Central Hospital where he was examined by a traumatologist, who diagnosed
two broken ribs and concluded that he needed “urgent hospitalization”. O.T. requested
permission to hospitalize him from the chief of the detention centre, A.D, who, in response
to this request, “did not say anything”. O.T. examined Mr. Rakishev twice on 6 May. On 8
May, she was present to witness his death.
4.14 Several witnesses confirmed O.T.’s testimony. For example, N.G., who was at the
time held in the same cell as Dmitry Rakishev, stated that Mr. Rakishev told him that he
had been beaten in a fight before being admitted to the detention centre. N.G. also testified
that he did not see anyone torturing Mr. Rakishev. The State party denies the allegation that
N.G. had been threatened or mistreated by the investigators.
4.15 Furthermore, the State party submits that Dmitry Rakishev’s father, Ashim Rakishev,
was recognized as a victim and as a representative of his deceased son on 1 August 2011.
2
3
4
The State party also submits that on 19 May 2011, the criminal case against Dmitry Rakishev was
discontinued due to death of the defendant.
Defined by the State party as “causing ‘moderate bodily injuries’”.