ESSEX PAPER 3: INITIAL GUIDANCE ON THE INTERPRETATION AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE UN NELSON MANDELA RULES
against Torture, for instance, has emphasised the fact that the confidentiality of medical data
persists beyond the transfer and/or release of an inmate.206
It was highlighted that measures must be taken to ensure that a prisoner taking any form of
medication is provided the respective medicine during transfer and upon arrival at the new facility.
Foreign national prisoners
The experts analysed Rule 62 in the light of the importance of contact with the outside world for
foreign national prisoners, although the Rule was not itself revised in the course of the review.207
Alongside Rule 62, the experts flagged the relevance of Rules 2(2), 54, 55 and 80(1) for foreign
national prisoners.
Given the high number of foreign national prisoners in many countries, practical guidance on how
to effectuate the revised standards for this group is of particular interest.208
As a starting point, the experts noted the relevance of Rule 2(2) in the context of foreign national
prisoners, stipulating that ‘taking account of individual needs of prisoners, in particular vulnerable
categories’ does not constitute discrimination.
The participants emphasised that access to rights such as legal aid, complaints procedures and
procedural safeguards depend on prisoners being provided with the means to exercise them,
including the ability to understand them and to communicate. The written information prisoners
ought to receive upon admission according to Rules 54 and 55 (prison law and regulations;
rights including legal advice and legal aid, requests and complaints; obligations and disciplinary
sanctions) therefore needs to be available ‘in the most commonly used languages in accordance
with the needs of the prison population’.
Should a prisoner not understand any of these languages, interpretation assistance should be
provided (Rule 55(1)). Creative solutions may be required, such as the availability of telephone
interpreters. The experts also highlighted that solutions imply the recruitment of prison staff taking
into account fluency in the languages common in a country’s prison population, as captured in Rule
80(1).209
Good practice in reducing the common isolation of foreign national prisoners has been enshrined in
the Council of Europe recommendations, suggesting that they be ‘allocated to prisons where there
are others of their nationality, culture, religion or who speak their language’. It is also recommended
that special attention is paid ‘to the maintenance and development of their relationships with the
outside world, including contacts with family and friends, consular representatives, probation
and community agencies and volunteers’.210 Recommendation 22.2. explicitly states that foreign
prisoners ‘shall be allowed to use a language of their choice during such contacts’ unless there
is ‘a specific concern in individual cases related to safety and security’. (See detailed provisions
UN Committee against Torture, Observations of the Committee against Torture on the revision of the United Nations
Standard Minimum Rules for the Treatment of Prisoners (SMR), 16 December 2013, CAT/C/51/4, para.21
206
See also UN Bangkok Rules, Rule 2(1) last sentence, which captures information about and the opportunity to access
consular representatives upon admission.
207
The Council of Europe, for example, has adopted specific recommendations concerning foreign prisoners (Council
of Europe, Recommendation CM/Rec (2012)12 of the Committee of Ministers to member States concerning foreign
prisoners, 10 October 2012 (CoE Recommendation on foreign prisoners)).
208
Rule 80(1): The prison director, his or her deputy, and the majority of other prison staff shall be able to speak the
language of the greatest number of prisoners, or a language understood by the greatest number of them.
209
CoE Recommendation on foreign prisoners, CM/Rec (2012)12, 16.3. and 22.1.
210
Penal Reform International and the Essex Human Rights Centre
| 59
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents