4. PRE-REMOVAL DETENTION CENTERS
4.a. Policy and legislative developments in 2019
This year was marked by key institutional developments, including the transfer of
37
migration competences from the Ministry of Migration and Asylum to the Ministry
of Citizen Protection and changes regarding the prerequisites for the administrative
detention of third-country nationals (L.4636/2019 entry into force on 1.1.2020).
Although, it is too early to assess this change of policy and namely its impact on the
detainees' living conditions and human rights that would allow a well-documented
overall assessment, the NPM is alert in order to ensure its compatibility with the
guidelines and priorities set by international and European legislation regarding
migration policies and conditions of freedom deprivation. In his intervention before
the competent parliamentary committee, the Ombudsman made extensive remarks
regarding the provisions of the introduced bill (voted as Law 4636/2019) and namely
the vague notion of the closed reception and identification centers that "shall be
organized according to the standards of pre-removal detention centers".
Among other, the Ombudsman commented on the prolongation of detention time
regarding minors, which also falls within the Mechanism's focus area. In particular,
there are issues with the expansion and prolongation of the administrative
detention of asylum seekers and namely with three policy choices: a) the provision
introducing general administration detention instead of the continuation of
detention only for asylum applicants b) the establishment of closed reception and
identification centers and c) the dissociation of the administrative detention time
from the administration time for returns. In that manner, the maximum time limits
set in the Directive 2008/115/EC "on common standards and procedures for
returning illegally staying third-country nationals" do not apply. It must be noted
that the 18 month-time limitation set by the Directive 2008/115/EC (para.5-6 of
article 15, ECJ Katzoev C-457/09 and Bashir Mohammed Ali Mahdi C-146/14) may
under no circumstances be violated. The proposed provision allowed for an 18 plus
18 detention period, which was unacceptable for a rule-of-law state. The Mechanism
has reiterated its solid objection regarding the administrative detention of minors
37
The Ministry of Immigration and Asylum was abolished after the 2019 parliamentary
elections and its competencies were transferred to the Ministry of Citizen Protection
(Presidential Decree 81/2019). The Ministry was subsequently re-established with Presidential
Decree 4/2020
47
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents