The Death Penalty in the OSCE Area–Background Paper 2021
It has been suggested that the legislative proposals were initiated to anticipate a risk
of death sentences imposed on individuals involved in the mass detention of peaceful protesters following the elections in August 2020.166
Areas of concern
Lack of transparency
Death sentences and executions in Belarus have been repeatedly criticized for the
lack of transparency and atmosphere of secrecy in which they take place. Relatives
are not informed in advance of the scheduled day of execution nor the burial place
of those executed. Belarussian law classifies information on the death penalty as a
“State secret”, which means that the convicted person, their lawyer and their family
are not informed about the time and place of the execution.
As the UN Special Rapporteur on the situation of human rights in Belarus has noted,
this lack of transparency traumatizes families of those affected by the death penalty
and can amount to inhuman treatment in violation of Article 7 of the ICCPR. She also
noted that pending abolition, the right to an effective appeal against death sentences
must be ensured in line with the ICCPR and family members of persons convicted and
sentenced to death must be informed about the date and place of the execution, and
also informed about the place of burial.167 The suffering and trauma experienced by
death row prisoners’ family members needs to be taken into account. There are reports about the stigma faced by relatives of those sentenced to death in Belarus and
limited services offered by the state specialized in psychological assistance agency
to the families of those executed.168
The anxiety often experienced on death row as a result of the uncertainty caused
by the threat of death at any time, can also cause severe psychological suffering for
convicted individuals and may amount to torture or other ill-treatment.169 Moreover,
the lack of transparency complicates the monitoring and reporting of death penalty cases.170
166 Viasna, Андрей Полуда: Власти хотят продать этот политический вопрос — отмену смертной казни
в Беларуси, [Andrei Paluda: authorities make this a political question – abolition of the death penalty in
Belarus], 6 January 2021.
167 Situation of human rights in Belarus, op. cit., note 144, p. 2 and 18.
168 BBC, op. cit., note 151.
169 Juan E. Méndez, “Interim report of the Special Rapporteur on torture and other cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment”, UN Doc. A/67/279, 9 August 2011, para. 50–51.
170 Situation of human rights in Belarus, op. cit., note 144, pp., 4–5.
42
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents