FACTSHEET
latter is a particularly useful opportunity to crosscheck detainee and police testimonies when there is
a suspicion of ill-treatment or abuse, alongside the
examination of medical records.
During its visit to Spain in 2011, the CPT
was able to observe on CCTV recording
that detainees were hooded and had to
walk backwards when they were moved
from their cell to the interrogation room, the
doctor’s room or to the toilet.17
Monitoring bodies using checklists or other types of
guidance during their visits can include the issue of CCTV
among issues to be addressed and assessed during
their inspections.18 They can also share their opinions
and recommendations with the authorities on the use
of CCTV in their visit reports. Where the use of CCTV
prompts significant concerns, monitoring mechanisms
may consider dedicating a thematic report or specific
sections of their annual reports to this issue.19
17. See, the CPT’s report to Spain, [CPT/Inf (2013) 6], para. 24, p22. Available at: http://www.cpt.coe.int/documents/esp/2013-06-inf-eng.pdf <accessed
23 October 2013>.
18. See for example Her Majesty’s Inspectorate of Constabulary (HMIC) (UK), Expectations for police custody, Version 2, 2012. Section 2 Treatment and
conditions, 3 (Custody staff are competent to assess and manage risks presented by detainees): ‘Observe whether the CCTV is working, whether it
records and how long the recordings are kept’ and 5 (Any force used within a custody suite is proportionate and lawful): ‘Check CCTV recording’ and
Section 3: Individual rights 13. All rights relating to PACE [Police and Criminal Evidence Act] are adhered to: ‘Check…video and audio recordings,
especially if detainees claim to have experienced oppressive conduct’. Available at https://www.justiceinspectorates.gov.uk/hmic/publications/
expectations-police-custody-criteria/ <accessed 18 November 2015>.
19. See for example the thematic report published by the Polish NPM on the issue (only available in Polish), 2012. Available at: http://www.rpo.gov.pl/
sites/default/ files/Raport%20monitoring%20wizytjny.pdf <accessed 23 October 2013>; or the 2009 annual report of the French NPM (only available in
French). Available at: http://www.cglpl.fr/2010/rapport-dactivite-2009/ <accessed 23 October 2013>.
Penal Reform International | Video recording in police custody: Addressing risk factors to prevent torture and ill-treatment
|7