CAT/OP/UKR/3
88.
Moreover, the Subcommittee observed that the vehicles used for such transfers were
dark, lacking in ventilation and divided into small, cramped cages, with one cage measuring
a mere 90 cm2. The Subcommittee is concerned about reports that detainees are not
provided food or water when they are transferred to participate in procedural actions and
court hearings, even when such transfers last several days.
89.
The Subcommittee recommends that the State party evaluate its system of
transfers to ensure that transfers are made only after appropriate justifications and
that they do not result in detainees being held in short-term detention centres, such as
ITTs, for lengthy periods. The Subcommittee also recommends that the State party
guarantee that fundamental safeguards, including access to the outside world, legal
counsel and medical care, are not unnecessarily interrupted by frequent transfers.
90.
The Subcommittee recommends that the State party replace vehicles lacking
sufficient space and ventilation. It also recommends that it discontinue the use of full
metal cages, which endangers detainees in transport. The Subcommittee further
recommends that the State party provide detainees with the food and water to which
they are entitled while deprived of their liberty.
Children and detention
Mother and baby units
91.
The Subcommittee positively notes the clean, bright and well-equipped premises for
mothers and babies in Chernihiv and Chornomorsk prison colonies. The Chernihiv unit, in
particular, includes a playroom, instruments and individual sleeping quarters where
detained mothers who have recently given birth can stay with their children. Nevertheless,
the Subcommittee considers that these premises can be further adapted for children. For
example, rooms for family visits are sterile and lack child-friendly decoration. Visiting
rooms in both locations have glass separators, which deprives detainees and their children
of the opportunity to bond with visitors in a familial atmosphere. Finally, pregnant women
are held with the general prison population in group dormitories located in older, poorly lit
facilities.
92.
Despite the relatively good material conditions in mother and baby units, the
Subcommittee is concerned about the psychological well-being of mothers kept there. It
notes with concern the fact that babies are separated from their mothers for several days
after birth and during periods of serious illness, which causes anxiety to mothers and could
hinder the socialization of their children. While mothers who have given birth live in bright,
en suite accommodations with their children in Chernihiv, in Chornomorsk mothers and
children do not live together but meet for only two hours twice a day, which is an
insufficient bonding period for children’s early development. In addition, as mothers and
children share mealtimes, mothers who wish to assist their children during that time must
forfeit their own food. The Subcommittee notes with approval the placement of a child
psychologist as head of unit in Chernihiv, where mothers and children also benefit from a
wide range of activities. However, comparable activities were not observed in
Chornomorsk, where there was a lack of records documenting detainees’ psychological and
psychiatric history. Moreover, detainees in Chornomorsk showed signs of emotional
distress, including tangible anxiety and visible laceration scars on the arms of some women.
93.
The Subcommittee is concerned about the treatment of women in Chornomorsk,
where abuse and forced labour have been reported. In particular, the Subcommittee has
received reports of staff and caregivers verbally abusing mothers and acting aggressively
towards their small children. During its visit, the Subcommittee observed detainees being
intimidated and made to stand upon the entrance of unit personnel. In addition, the
Subcommittee has been made aware of harsh measures, including isolation for up to 10
days and separation from children, imposed as disciplinary measures for infractions. The
Subcommittee further notes that all non-pregnant women detained there are required to
work, for negligible compensation. In addition, it is alleged that mothers have been
punished as retribution for reporting abuses, including by being forced to carry out
uncompensated manual labour.
94.
The Subcommittee recommends that the State party adapt units
accommodating mothers and children to enhance familial bonding between detained
15
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents