Female Wing
It had 4 cells and one disciplinary cell, all the occupants of which I spoke to. The
latter had one inmate, who had been there for 7 months. The other prisoners
stated that the lone occupant was violent and fought the former.
Complaints - insufficient food and poor health care; two inmates had no one
to visit them or bring them food.
Juveniles Wing
One of them complained of being given medicine which had expired while
another complained that he had not received the drug which had been prescribed
for him. The food was described as bad.
I considered the following complaints as so serious as to bring them to the
immediate attention of the Director. A particular guard was identified as
mistreating the juveniles. While generally the doors to their cell were closed at
8 p.m. and opened at 7 a.m., the guard in question would sometimes keep the
door closed in day time for 4 weeks continuously. He would also not allow
them to go out to buy food. The Director promised to investigate and take
remedial action.
Male Wing
5 cells housing 49, 65, 63, 64 and 65 prisoners respectively were visited. They
were all very crowded with pots and pans as well as clothes hanging on the
walls. The cells had ceiling fans.
Some of the prisoners had no mats, and slept on cardboards. There were quite
a number of the inmates who complained of long remand ranging from 7 years.
Lokono Joseph claimed that he had been on remand for 12 years as a murder
suspect.
Other complaints (some stated in direct speech of the Complainants)
Corruption in the judiciary and injustice in the penal regime. The food is
insufficient and of poor quality. No one in the prison attends to the health needs
of the prisoners, and the prison had no medicine. They will receive prescription,
but have no means to buy the medicine.
"One boy died about 2 weeks ago because he did not have money to
buy medicine when he was sick. He was sick for 3 months without
medical attention."
14
"Government does not provide jobs and so young people fall into
criminality."
"If you come from a poor family, there is no hope for you."
Soap is supplied once in two weeks, but sometimes once in a month. Some
inmates have no visits.
Disciplinary Cell
The occupant of the cell stated that he had been there for 3 months. It was
however spacious.
Mr. Philibert Sorou
As we were leaving the prison, the above prisoner ran after us. He had been taken
into custody as a murder suspect, but he himself had sustained a gunshot wound,
probably self-inflicted in course of the conduct which had led to the deprivation
of his liberty. However his wound was created, it was a pathetic sight. One did
not have to be a doctor to conclude that life was ebbing out of him.
What should be done with him alternated between discharge and hospitalisation.
Against the former course of action, there was no certainty that his end would
not soon come for lack of adequate medical care. The latter was, therefore,
decided upon; and it says so much for the understanding and co-operation of
the relevant authorities in Benin that in a matter of days, and while we were still
in Benin, Mr. Sorou was admitted into hospital for surgery.
Mr. Antoine Gouhouede, Parquet Porto-Novo, who had to sign a warrant to get
Mr. Sorou out of prison was a model of a gentleman. He set aside all that he
was doing in his office, expressed regret that the Director of the Prison had not
brought Mr. Sorou's condition to the former's attention. The magistracy could
have sent the prisoner to hospital; and at the worst civil society groups could have
helped.
Beyond the lone case of Mr. Sorou, Mr. Gouhouede acknowledged the problem
of long remand. The danger and fear was that, when allowed to go home to turn
up for trial suspects would disappear. A number of them come from Nigeria,
and they slip across the border beyond the reach of the authorities in Benin. But
it is important that early trial is given those on remand.
15
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents