CAT/OP/NZL/1
104. The Subcommittee is further concerned with the record-keeping system, which is in
dire need of improvement. It noted that information about refugees and asylum seekers was
not easily ascertainable and that some copies of court warrants and records of social
allowances were missing in individual files.
105. The Subcommittee recommends that the State party expedite the rebuilding of
the Mangere refugee and asylum centre, with a view to ensuring that living conditions
respect the dignity of refugees and asylum seekers.
106. The State party should also, as a matter of urgency, improve record-keeping at
the Mangere refugee and asylum centre, ensuring that information concerning
refugees and asylum seekers is easily accessible and accurate.
G.
Border facilities
Wellington International Airport
107. While noting that, reportedly, detention at the police station at Wellington
International Airport rarely exceeded three hours, the Subcommittee was concerned that the
premises did not permit detainees of different genders to be held separately, there being
only one cell.
Auckland Airport
108. The Subcommittee commends the material conditions of the immigration day-room
facilities, where persons awaiting their flights are held for periods of normally less than
three hours. It also noted the professionalism of the staff in charge of the facility.
109. The Subcommittee noted that persons of foreign origin who had been refused entry
were treated differently, depending on the airline that had been arranged for their departure,
because transport and the use of escorts were at the discretion of each airline.
H.
Transportation of detainees
110. The Subcommittee inspected two types of vehicles used by the Corrections
Department for transferring prisoners by road: vans with single metal compartments for
holding prisoners individually and vehicles with collective benches. Through interviews
with detainees and information received from custodial staff, the Subcommittee learned that
during transportation in vehicles with single “cages”, which were used most often,
prisoners were routinely handcuffed and often restrained at the waist, regardless of their
individual security classification. While accepting that some prisoners may require to be
transported in conditions of extreme security to prevent escape, aggression or self-harm, the
Subcommittee is of the view that these measures are excessive and should not be
customarily applied to all prisoners at all times. Moreover, the Subcommittee considers that
transfers in small cages with metal benches and without proper windows for long journeys
(up to 12 hours) fall short of a humane system of transportation. The Subcommittee was
also concerned that the design of the vehicles prevented both the monitoring of the
prisoners’ condition by custodial staff and the effective communication of prisoners with
the driver.
111. Regarding transfers of detainees by air, the Subcommittee expresses its utmost
concern at the alleged practice of routinely using handcuffs, waist restraints and, in
particular, at the suggestion that on some flights all prisoners are attached to a chain down
the centre of the plane throughout the flight. As with transfers by road, the extreme security
20
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents