E/CN.4/1995/34
page 43
Four prisoners - Hassanein Moustafa, Youssri Abdel-Mesih, Atef Aboul-Futouh
Ahmed and El-Mohamadei Mohamed Mursi - were reported to have died in the
incident. Mohamed Ahmed El-Sadeq reportedly sustained an injury to his right
thigh from a live bullet.
217. The Government replied that on 5 September 1993, not 27 August 1993,
Abu Zaabal prison had been the scene of riots and acts of violence among
inmates in which three persons died and 85 other persons suffered superficial
injuries. During the incident of 24 October, the force responsible for law
and order was attacked by some inmates while conducting routine search
operations, resulting in injury to 25 members of the force and 52 inmates as
well as the death of one inmate. The injured persons were treated and the DPP
ordered a medical examination to determine the cause of the deceased
prisoner’s death.
218. A similar campaign was reportedly carried out at Marg prison
on 13 September 1993 and 22 September 1993. In the first incident,
Hatem Musaad El-Qanaoui and Ashraf Abdel-Sitar Ahmed allegedly sustained
severe injuries as a result of assaults with sticks and wire. In the second
incident, injuries by beating were allegedly inflicted upon Ahmed Farghali,
Abdul-Haggag Gohar, Abdel Menem Abdel-Hafez, Mohamed Hussein, Mohamed Hussein
El-Shaarawi, Mohamed Abdel-Maged, Ramadan Gomaa and Sami Ahmed.
219. The Government replied that on 13 May 1993, not 13 September, some of
the inmates at Al-Marg prison rioted and committed acts of violence which
compelled the prison administration to intervene to disperse the rioters and
arrest the instigators. Sixteen inmates were charged with using force against
public officials and causing deliberate damage and 11 of these persons were
convicted by the criminal court at Benha.
220. The Government further notified the Special Rapporteur
on 17 November 1994 that the following persons convicted in Military Felony
Cases 18 and 24/1993 had been summoned by the DPP from their places of
detention to give statements: Muhammad Samir Ebeid al-Sayyid, Khalid Abdul
Fattah Hassan Mustafa, Muhammad Ali Muhammad Mutawalli, Khalifa Abdul Azim
Abdul Aziz Khalifa, Yahya Khalafallah Muhammad Ali, Rabi Ahmad Rikabi Ahmad,
Ra’id Abdul Sami’ Ali Amara, Ahmad Shawqi Thabit Abdul Al, Abdul Rahim Abdul
Ghaffar Marsi Abdul Bari, and Muhammad Gallal Ahmad (Military Felony Case 18);
Samir al-Sayyid Mahmoud Raihan, Yaseen Abdul Sattar Yaseen, Gamal Muhammad Abu
Zeid Sulaiman, Amru Ali Muhammad al-Iraqi, Islam Ragab Abdul Hadi, Khalifa Abu
Zeid Shabib Hilal, Tariq Mutawalli Ahmad al-Tukhi, and Yasir Haggag Muhammad
Haggag (Military Felony Case 24). Those persons claiming to have been
subjected to assault or torture were sent for medical examinations. In none
of their statements did the prisoners identify the persons responsible for the
alleged assault.
Urgent appeals
221. On 7 March 1994 the Special Rapporteur sent an urgent appeal on behalf
of Kamel Soliman, a Christian, who was arrested on 31 July 1993 in Cairo by
members of the security forces for distributing a book written by a former
Muslim who had converted to Christianity. He allegedly was subjected to
torture at the State Security Building, including by suspension from the
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents