ANNUAL REPORT OF 2019 ON THE ACTIVITIES OF THE SEIMAS OMBUDSMEN’S OFFICE OF THE REPUBLIC OF LITHUANIA
provides that Member States shall take appropriate
measures to ensure that suspects and accused
persons are not presented guilty in court or in public
by means of physical restraint, has not been properly
transposed into national law and Lithuania does
not take all measures to ensure that suspects and
accused persons are not presented guilty in court
or in public by means of physical restraint.
Data collected during the investigation revealed that
officers do not always use video recording devices
to perform their tasks, so cases of physical abuse
are often unrecorded. In the opinion of the Seimas
Ombudsman, such practice of law enforcement
officers creates preconditions for the risk of violations
of human rights.
The investigation also found that the problem of
use of excessive physical abuse in practice still
existed. It is therefore necessary to take measures
to ensure that officials comply strictly with legal
acts regulating their activities, assess and take
into account the particular situation, the nature
of the legal offence, the individual characteristics
of the offender, the level of resistance, and the
consequences of the use of a specific coercive
measure in order to ensure that suspects and
accused persons, who do not resist and pose
no danger to officers, are not subjected to
disproportionate use of violence towards them
and are not presented guilty in court or in public.
Taking into account the circumstances established
during the investigation, the Seimas Ombudsman
recommended to the Minister of Justice to ensure
proper transposition of provisions of Directive
2016/343 of the European Parliament and the
Council of 9 March 2016 (EU) into national law, in
order to ensure that suspects and accused persons
are not presented in court or in public as guilty by
means of physical restraint, to the Minister of Justice
and the Minister of the Interior of the Republic of
Lithuania – to amend the Convoy Rules so as to
ensure that officers exercising their right to apply
special measures in the cases specified in this
EVERYONE COUNTS
22
paragraph, do not exceed the powers conferred
on them by laws regulating their activities, and law
enforcement agencies – to take measures to ensure
that officers use physical coercion in compliance with
the conditions for use of physical coercion laid down
by legal acts and only in exceptional cases, when
less severe sanctions are (may be) ineffective, all
instances of physical coercion are recorded and
evaluated in accordance with the procedure laid
down by legal acts, ensuring timely, appropriate,
effective use of video recording devices when officers
perform the tasks related to the potential need to
apply coercive measures.
Investigation into the fundamental
human rights problems arising from
activities of the officers of the
State Security Department (SSD)
of the Republic of Lithuania
The Seimas Ombudsman initiated the investigation
into the fundamental human rights problems at
the State Security Department of the Republic of
Lithuania9, during which the compliance of the legal
acts regulating the activities of the SSD and internal
control with the standards of protection of human
rights and freedoms was also assessed.
During the investigation it was established that
decisions taken by the SSD officers to sanction the
use of technical means according to the general
procedure (i.e. without sanctioning by court),
neither before nor after their adoption, are not
assessed by an independent competent authority,
such assessment is not established in legal acts, and,
accordingly, the question of the risk of abuse of
power by officers using technical means according
to the general procedure should be raised. It has
9
Certificate-Report No 4D-2018/1-897 of the Seimas
Ombudsman of 20 December 2019 on human rights
problems at the State Security Department of the Republic
of Lithuania.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents