deprivation of liberty. The monitoring results raise security concerns such as conflicts
between the prison administration and the prisoners, which is exacerbated by
inadequate reaction or lack of reaction of penitentiary officials in specific situations,
improper follow-up on complaints and lack of awareness by prisoners of the services
available to them. The level of knowledge and qualifications of the prison staff are
insufficient. Against this background, the prisoners are often resorting to hunger
strikes and injuring themselves. A high risk of violence among prisoners and the
impact of criminal mentality in penitentiary institutions are a serious problem. This is
what makes it necessary to introduce a system that would ensure maintaining good
order and security in prisons according to international standards; in particular, it is
necessary to actually implement the concept of dynamic security and develop a wellthought-through plan for management of incidents and emergencies.
Unfortunately the moving of prisoners from one institution to another remained a
frequent practice in 2014. The Public Defender’s Office is unable to evaluate whether
or not the individual decisions to transfer prisoners between different prisons
were reasonable because, according to an official explanation by the Penitentiary
Department, the decisions are based on secret letters authored by prison directors;
since these letters contain criminal intelligence information, the Public Defender’s
representatives have no right to access them. Our observation is that prisoners are
often moved from the penitentiary institutions located in the eastern Georgia to those
located in the eastern Georgia and vice versa. It is for that reason that the prisoners
have difficulty to maintain contact with their families and lawyers and are experiencing
additional stress related to adaptation to the changed environment.
In regard to movement of prisoners, the Special Preventive Group also inspected
the vehicles designated for moving prisoners and concluded that the conditions of
transportation are unsatisfactory and represent a serious nuisance for prisoners.
Furthermore, we found out that inside a Mercedes vehicle designed for moving the
prisoners there is a small-size metal booth (with an area of about 0.3 square meters),
which is narrow, is not aerated and it is completely dark inside. The booth is usually
used to transport women prisoners and prisoners who belong to sexual minorities.
The Special Preventive Group believes that placing an individual in such booths is a
degrading treatment and the booths must be removed.
Ensuring proper conditions to prisoners requires a great deal of attention. Compared
to previous years, the physical environment and hygiene have improved in a number of
penitentiary institutions. However, the existing conditions in the Georgian penitentiary
institutions are still leaving a lot of room for improvement. Some of the common
problems are: insufficient artificial ventilation in residential cells, quarantine cells and
solitary confinement cells; insufficient natural light and ventilation; short time for
outdoor exercising and lack of exercising opportunities in closed institutions; lack of
required equipment and conditions in the yards of penitentiary institutions designed
for outdoor exercising; and lack of infrastructure to support long-term visits.
NATIONAL PREVENTIVE MECHANISM OF GEORGIA
13
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents