CAT/C/32/D/225/2003
Page 3
1.1
The complainant is Mr. R.S., an Indian citizen, who at the time of the initial
submission resided in Denmark, where he sought asylum. His current
whereabouts are unknown. He claims that his return to India after the rejection
of his refugee claim would constitute a violation by Denmark of article 3 of
the Convention. He is represented by counsel.
1.2
In accordance with article 22, paragraph 3, of the Convention, the Committee
transmitted the complaint to the State party on 21 November 2002.
The facts as submitted:
2.1
The complainant grew up in Bilga (India), in the Philour area, in the district of
Punjab, where he lived together on a farm with his parents and 2 brothers. All
family members are Sikhs. The complainant went to school for 7 years, before
entering into the family farming business. While his uncle and older brother
became members of the Sikh Students Federation and the Khalistan
Commando Force (KCF), the complainant did not himself participate in any
political or religious organizations. In 1994, the complainant’s uncle was
killed by the police. The avowed aim of the KCF is to obtain independence for
Punjab.
2.2
In 1995, the complainant’s older brother returned to India from Germany,
where he had applied for asylum. The police arrested and detained him for
about 10-12 days after his arrival, and detained him further on several
occasions, until he disappeared on an unspecified date. On 15 September
1997, the police contacted the complainant and asked for information on the
whereabouts of his brother. When he replied that he did not know his brother’s
whereabouts, he was arrested and detained for 10 days. He contends that he
was subjected to torture in detention. In April 1998, the complainant was again
questioned about the whereabouts of his brother by the police, he was
allegedly threatened with death if he did not provide this information.
2.3
The complainant was subsequently detained by the police on several
occasions, and subjected to torture when in detention. This included beating
with a cane, being subjected to electrical shocks, and being hung upside down.
According to the complainant, his problems with the police arose from the fact
that he transmitted messages sent between his brother and other people from a
neighbor village. He was detained 10 to12 times in total before in June 1999,
he escaped to Denmark, with the assistance of a paid agent.
2.4
The complainant arrived in Denmark on 17 July 1999 without valid travel
documents. He applied for asylum the next day. A brother of his already
resided in Denmark since 1998, and had been granted a residence permit
pursuant to the article 7, paragraph 1 of the Immigration Act. The complainant
applied for a residence permit under the same regulations, but the Danish
Immigration Board rejected his application on 12 February 2001.