Section two Focus on detention issues
Isolation – guidance for NPM
monitoring bodies
The NPM began work to develop
comprehensive guidance to strengthen
its monitoring of isolation in detention.
This guidance was developed on the basis
of the findings of the review of isolation
and solitary confinement across detention
settings conducted by NPM members in
2014–15, and draws from international and
best practice. It will be published in 2016–17.
The guidance will provide a comprehensive
framework that NPM members should apply
when examining isolation in detention, which
has the potential to give rise to ill-treatment.
It aims to improve the consistency with
which NPM members monitor the issues. At
the same time, the guidance will allow NPM
members to identify and promote good and
improved practice, and will provide a basis
on which to formulate recommendations to
strengthen policy.
Immigration detention
In November 2015, NPM members
discussed the UK’s unique situation of having
no statutory time limit on immigration
detention. The UK has opted out of the EU
Returns Directive, which sets a maximum
time limit of six months (and 18 months in
exceptional circumstances). This situation has
been criticised by a number of international
human rights bodies, including most recently
the UN Human Rights Committee, which
called on the UK to ‘establish a statutory
time limit on the duration of immigration
detention and ensure that detention is a
measure of last resort and is justified as
reasonable, necessary and proportionate in
the light of the relevant circumstances’.
The Scottish Human Rights Commission
proposed that in light of the significant
harm caused by indefinite detention, and
considering the NPM’s responsibility under
OPCAT to make recommendations that take
into account relevant UN standards, the NPM
should take a position on the issue. Some
individual NPM members have already called
for there to be a time limit. As a result, NPM
members agreed that the NPM should call
for a time limit on immigration detention.
25
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents